Reviews for Pudgy's Pizza & Pasta in Pine Bush, NY
We eat here 3 times a week or more. We have been a customer for over 10 years. The owner luey is so welcoming . He has great... staff and great food Recently we have had Maddie as our waitress and she is absolute doll! You can tell they all the workerslove there job. Which results from having a great boss. The food is great and customer service is 5 star. Read more
Great food and reasonable price. We have tried both the Italian and Mexican food and both are really good. This place was great... the first few times we went but now it's not as good. I asked for onion rings instead of French fries and got literally fouronion rings. Last time I got a full portion so I don't know if they changed cooks but this is so disappointing and not worth the20 minute ride. Edit: The past few times we've gone here it had been better but still hit or miss. I am guessing it depends onwho is working that day. Overall good food and lots of options. Read more
Do yourself a favor and do not go here. Do not waste your money. Go somewhere else. Anywhere else. Back in the day Pudgy?s had... good food? not anymore. Ordered $60 worth of food and none of it was good. I could have made better Italian food myself. Theguac was awful too. What a disappointment. Happened to be in Pine Bush and thought I?d get take out from there. What a mistake. Read more
I bought two dozen hot wings on 4/23. They didn?t inform me they?re Tyson frozen wings. Total trash. I threw them out because... so bad. Shameful! The guacamole was also from a bag so that was sub-par as well. Pizza also black on the bottom and covered wflour since they apparently are too lazy or think we?re stupid which motivates them to be total pigs. I can only wonder whatelse they do there to cut corners and deceive customers. Very disappointing since I remember when the place was good and hadgood food. Pudgy?s 2022 not like Pudgy?s 2019. Sad. Beware! Read more
All food is made fresh. The cooks take pride in their dishes. A huge selection of food on the menu from salads to sandwiches to... Mexican and Italian dishes. Pudgy's is my #1 choice for lunch when I'm in the Pine Bush area. The only downside is the diningarea is not big enough for parties of more than 4 people. Read more
For years Leo's in Newburgh has been my favorite pizza and untill now have never found another pizza that could contend with... Leo's. The pizza here was fantastic. Good thick slice that was perfectly cooked all the way through with a good balance of sauceand cheese. Sadly they don't deliver and are 20 ish minutes away but I'll definitely return in the future for more. It was veryvery good. Read more
& local pizza joint. Sandwiches, Italian specials, pizza, pizza by the slice. Non-alcoholic fountain drinks as well as bottled... beverages. Pizza was tasty. Restaurant was clean and staff was pleasant & order was accurate. Read more
I have never had pizza I could not eat. This pizza was not good. It had so much cheese on it my son almost choked on it. We... ate in the restaurant and I had to ask twice for cups so we could share our big bottle of soda. No straws were offered. I hadheard good things about them and was disappointed by the experience. Read more