Reviews for Don Pepe Steakhouse in Pine Brook, NJ
Had a VERY thick T-bone cooked perfectly! Delicious alone or with mushroom gravy! Even though I thought things were a bit pricy... you get what you pay for and the value is there. You will not be disappointed! Read more
Service was great and the food was even better.
We had a 60th birthday for 20 people last night and everything was beyond amazing! The food was endless and cooked to... perfection, spirits were replenished as needed and they were so attentive and accommodating! Everyone at the party had a greattime and raved about the food and hospitality! Thank you to the staff and to Joe for planning an amazing menu and for us aseverything was perfect! Book your next party there and you won?t be sorry! ???? Read more
Really enjoyed the food and the people around the bar. The food was excellent especially the risotto.
Consistently good food and service every time we come to this restaurant. The prices are a bit high, but the portions are huge.... Really. We always have lots left overs to take home. If you're not big on leftovers, split an entrée. Our favorite appetizer isthe perfectly cooked garlic shrimp. We sop up the sauce with bread. Who cares who's watching! Paella isn't on the menu but youcan order it. It was enough to feed four people a healthy portion and six people a medium portion. My husband loves steaks andhe says their porterhouse is excellent. Recommend, but expect to pay a bit. Read more
Service was good though it was odd they didnt go over the days specials nor did they ask if we wanted any pepper on our plates.... Calamari were good not great. I question the quality when there arent any tentacles but that's just me. Steaks were cooked rightand absolutely delicious. The chicken cutlet wasnt breaded which surprised us but it was good. I was told the shrimp andlinguini plate was very good and I could see it was a very large portion with lots of shrimp. No special sauces or marinades forour dishes but everyone enjoyed their dish. The indoor table spacing was reasonable with covid restrictions. I enjoyed my mealand would go back for sure but I'm not screaming off a mountaintop for it. Read more
Nice, clean restaurant with attentive staff. The garlic shrimp appetizer was good. I ordered the queen sirloin medium and it was... cooked perfectly. Huge portion, I couldn't even eat half. The red sangria tasted a little watered down. The special watermelonsherbet was really good. Read more
Excellent food. Beautiful place. Easy access.i just facilitated a Life Celebration here. The staff couldn?t have been more... accommodating and flexible. The varieties and quality of food was wonderful. Worth every dollar. Read more