Reviews for Captain Jim's Seafood Buffet in Pigeon Forge, TN
Is it 5 star dining with cloth napkins and table clothes...NO! But it is all you can eat fried seafood, clams(fried and steamed)... ,raw oysters, muscles, shrimp and crabs... not to be confused with king crabs. They aren't and won't be that big. So if youenjoy all you can eat seafood paper napkins very friendly staff that won't let you go thirsty and a shell bucket on the tableand dessert that is included. Then you'll appreciate this place for what it is. This place deserves a higher rating! Read more
Wow this place was packed and let me tell you it was well worth the wait! Delicious hot crab legs and all the other foods were... perfectly done. Your choice of a free scrumptious dessert afterwards! Read more
I wondered how a seafood buffet could have such mediocre ratings, but I discovered it was incredibly accurate. This is the most... mediocre buffet I think I could recommend. It's not terrible, but it's also not great. *IF YOU ARE NOT GOING FOR THE CRAB LEGS -your selections will otherwise be extremely limited. There is a salad bar, a bar with the crab legs and a handful of sides, anda third bar with a small assortment of other meats, including (at the time of my visit): fried catfish, fried Flounder(allegedly), fried clams, fried frog legs, crayfish, fried shrimp, and baked Cod. We DID get the crab legs, but they were justsmall, boiled crab legs... Pretty standard stuff. Can't say I would make this a regular stopping point on our frequent trips toPF/Sevierville. Read more
We got the buffet with all you can eat crab legs! They were so good! I didn't try alot of the other items but the crab legs were... well stocked they kept them full & hot! The price was I believe market price & it was $49 but definitely worth it! We will beback again! Read more
Really close to a 5 star, just missing a little from a facility stand point. Service was good and food was decent. They had... pretty much everything you would want from a seafood standpoint. Food wasn't quite your 5 star seafood, but for a buffet it wasbetter than expected. We loved the crab legs...no, they aren't the monster kind crab legs, but they were cooked well and ofdecent size. You get to eat all you want! I would def recommend and will be going back. Read more
Very satisfied with the buffet. We were here 2 years ago and enjoyed the place so came back since we were driving by. The price... did increase for the all you can eat crabs. But for the selection of seafood and quality of the food we weren?t too disappointedwith the price. Read more
I had all you can eat crab legs for $50.00. That was not a bad price to me because everything has gone up, gas, groceries, ... prescriptions,etc.They were big, taste good and they never ran out. My husband ate the buffet and enjoyed it. Read more
As a non seafood lover, it was okay for what they had. That's certainly understandable since it's a seafood restaurant. Now for... the rest of my family who loved seafood, (especially crab) this is where you want to go. It's hard to find crab on a buffetanywhere so when you do, you go. They loved it and would have gone back if we had more time. Read more