Reviews for My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria Arcadia in Phoenix, AZ

Small, locally owned and operated pizzeria that rocks! Thin crust pizzas that are crispy but not brittle and hold up to sauces... and toppings. Great salads especially the Caesar and generous lunch specials. The slices are a good portion. The crust iscritical to any pizza and their's is great. The place is clean, not fancy.Some alcohol for sale, softdrinks and iced tea. Ilove their wings! Plenty of sauce options including choices for the pizza. Great vibe, lovely owner, and recommended to all. Read more

Always great pizza and wings! They make my sons favorite cheeseless pizza because he can't have dairy! Daniel and everyone at My... Slice is great and makes your feel like you have a friend in the neighborhood! Read more

We moved here in June of 2022 and tried this place on a whim because we saw there was El pastor pizza. How could you go wrong?... Boy did we lover everything we had. We've eaten here at least 10 times (between eat in and order out) this is in the top pizzajoints I've ever been too. You can order any pizza on the menu and be happy with what you got. Then there's the cheese bread.OH. MY. GAWD. Divine. I seriously am trying to get a way for Dave portnoy come do a review of this place. It's that good. Theservice is always so good and the people working there are so friendly. Lastly DONT skip on the cheesecake. (Especially the pbcup cheesecake) Read more

If the Doctor told me to Medicate myself with pizza this is what I would choose. It?s also dangerous because its in the same... center as Bosa donuts Which I shall now call-food crack corner. The Dough was exactly as it should taste for a New York stylepizza, the sauce flavoring was on point, and I should?ve ordered extra cheese because it was that good. I don?t know what I?mgonna do with myself because it?s only five minutes from my place but I appreciate the fact that I have the option. ???????????? Read more

Crust: thin and crunchy, definitely my favorite kind of crust Flavor: Bomb! Full of flavor and fresh ingredients Service: 5 star... service, they pay attention to details and they really care about their customers Honestly coming from MA to AZ its been veryhard finding a really good pizza shop. This place has it all and will now be my go to spot even after trying it one time!Everything about my pizza was spot on so please go try it!!!! Read more

Nice local place. I love the elongated table with the built in checker board and the detailed mural on the wall, it's an awesome... vibe.. but what really shocked me was the menu!! Homemade wing sauces, carne asada pizza, elote flatbread, I couldn't decidewhat to get! Everything hand crafted and unique. I'm definitely coming back to try it all! And Daniel is amazing! Customerservice on point Read more

Creative and unique take on pizza! We loved all the pizzas we tried, but the El Blanco and Al Pastor were exceptional! On top of... that, the crust is crunchy, chewy, and so delicious!! Can?t wait to try everything else. Highly recommend if you want to explorea new take on pizza. Read more

Had the opportunity to try out this little gem. The cashier was really nice. I got 2 cheese pizzas. The cheese was really... good. The crust was crispy and very chewy. Wasn?t a fan of the sauce. We also got wings the medium. They were good. Also thecheese bread was good. Read more