Reviews for Old Mill Hot Dog Stand in Phelps, NY
Really, really good food. Burger was A+. Reasonable prices, good portion for under 20$. Very impressed. I'd take pictures but... it's all gone. Read more
An impressive selection of hard ice cream; soft serve in limited flavors also available. Very generous portions!
Food is greasy and workers have an attitude. Definitely went down hill from years past. Couldn?t even finish my dinner due to... extra grease not to mention took almost an hour to get. I know this buisness is stressful at times as I used to work in the foodindustry but you cannot run a buisness like this. I get some of these people are first season workers but proper training isimportant so they are not running around clueless. I know they are trying their best and it?s not on them it?s on the boss man.Not to mention I tried to get my daughters party catered by this place but after weeks of trying to get ahold of him with noluck I went elseware. Read more
I got a blt. The bread was a little burnt and it could have used more mayo. My grandkids had grilled cheese and both were a bit... burnt but they said it was good. My husband had 2 hot dogs. A red hot with hot meatsauce, he didn't like that it had cinnamon init, and a white hot with mustard and sauerkraut. My daughter had a white hot with ketchup and beans which she enjoyed. Herhusband ha a cheeseburger and curly fries he said were great. We also had milk shakes that were delicious and thick. Loganberrydrinks,yum. Then ice cream of many flavors that were great and generously sized. Read more
It was pretty much what you'd expect in a place like this. We stopped for ice cream and had a decent time. They had a dog option... and our newest addition was overjoyed. It was a bit expensive but, considering it was a treat, worth it. I'd probably go thereagain. Read more
I can only speak to their chicken BBQ catering which they provided for my church in Huron. I've been involved with many chicken... BBQ and that was definitely one of the best I've tasted. Their coleslaw had a bit of a kick to it that I loved though mygranddaughter didn't at all. Everything was provided, chicken, coleslaw, salt potatoes, roll and butter, takeout containers andplastic ware. Very very good!! I know they are struggling like a lot of people to get the restaurant up and fully running dueto lack of workers. Give them a try. You won't be disappointed. Read more
Friendly staff. We had a group of 9 there last night. Lots of outdoor seating. Service was fast. I got the Brownie Sundae and... told them to make it as chocolaty as they wanted. They did not disappoint.... After dessert, we walked down to the creek andenjoyed the water for a few minutes (picture taken at the park). Although we did not try, they do have gluten free bread andwraps!!!! Read more
Took over 30 minutes to get our order with just a couple people ahead of us. The burgers tasted like cheap frozen patties... warmed up. The only reason I added a star was because my son loved the foot long hot dog. Read more