Loading

Reviews for Seester's Mexican Cantina in Pewaukee, WI

Scott T 2 years ago
5

Where to start? This wasn?t Tex-Mex. It wasn?t SoCal-Mex. It wasn?t even Pueblo-New Mex! And it certainly wasn?t some dainty... nouvelle cuisine mexicaine pablum you?d get at a boutique restaurant. These flavors were bold ? the portions plentiful ? ingredients fresh ? the red and green chile were made from scratch! That?s right, the ?sauces? are legit! I?ve had Mexican foodin every place you?d expect to find it, but this was totally unexpected. This uniquely mid-western Mexican fare standsunparalleled; boldly subtle, richly seasoned, simply mouth-watering. Our party of five ordered practically one of everything onthe menu. Nothing disappointed. We?re still begging Lynn and Wendy (The Seesters) for recipes and have offered to invest in afranchise in the PNW! We will make this a regular stop on our travels. PS: the drink menu is super awesome ???????????? Read more

Linda Dabrowski 2 years ago
4

Side walk seating was very fun. But a few more umbrellas would be nice. Service was great. Prices were fare in relation to... portions. We enjoyed what we ordered. Downtown Pewaukee has been beautifully revitalized since I was last there. Some of took awalk to the Beach Bum Bakery. Yummm Read more

Krista Konetzke 2 years ago
5

Great atmosphere with fantastic food. Small menu but lots of great options. The view of the lake really adds to the charm.

Keith Rabe 2 years ago
5

Service and presentation were exceptional. We were seated outside and then it began to rain. They worked with the patrons to get... them seated inside immediately. They absolutely took everything in stride. The first thing to arrive at our table was theseasoned chips and a variety of 5 dips including guacamole. The food that arrived looked top notch with the sour cream drizzledon like you see on the cooking shows. I would have preferred a bit more heat. All in all, I really enjoyed the experience. I'lldefinitely come back when it is not raining! Read more

Matt Krueger 2 years ago
4

Had the nacho supreme minus the beens. My Mom had the chicken quesadilla which she liked very much. The salsa was salty. The... seasoned chips were really good. Plus a great view of the beach and pewaukee lake. Read more

Jason Ellison 2 years ago
5

Good food and better people watching. We sat outside on the patio area and enjoyed the beach view. The waitresses were very... friendly and the prices were more reasonable than many other options in the same area. Read more

Jasmyne 3 years ago
5

My family and I absolutely love it here! Food is fabulous! My favorite are the shrimp enchiladas with poblano cream sauce and a... fresh genuine marg! The fresh guacamole and pico with seasoned chips are a must for me!! Staff is very friendly, personable, andattentive.. and to top it off you can?t beat the outdoor dining with a beautiful view of the lake! I Highly recommend dininghere ???? Read more

Deborah Bair 3 years ago
4

We started out on the patio but due to the weather, we moved inside. Restaurant was not too busy. Seester's does not serve... complimentary chips and salsa. Margarita was worth the price due to the amount of Patron Tequila. We order a ground beef burritowhich was very delicious. Ample amount of food for that dinner plate. Enough to share. We also ordered 2 Street Tacos...steakand fried avocado. Had to bring left overs home. Beautiful views of Pewaukee Beach. Read more