Reviews for Shoeless Joe's Sports Grill in Peterborough, ON

Showed up on a Saturday night during a Leafs game during the second period nobody noticed me come in so it wasn't till the game... ended that I actually had someone come to give me a menu or ask about a drink the girl behind the bar was the only one left totend to the restaurant and the bar seem to be a slow night but everyone was just going about their own business the girl whoserved me was wonderful and the food was all right for the price. Lots of TVs to watch sports if you wanted to go and catch agame and be undisturbed by people trying to sell you stuff that might be your best bet. But if you hope to have a diningexperience you may need to call ahead and make a reservation or yell out as you walk in so you don't go unnoticed like I did Read more

The atmosphere was awesome! They had a trivia game going (Thursdays). I got there in the middle so he said I could play the next... round but he forgot to give me the paper ???? The drinks were good! The appetizers were good! Our meals however were really bad,I couldn?t eat mine and ether could my other party. They did credit one meal. I did leave hungry and sad. Read more

Went here for dinner before a concert. Place is huge. Got seated fast and drink order taken and filled quickly. Food order was... taken and came in a timely manner. But she put food down and left. Never asked if we needed another drink. No utensils nonapkins. Nobody ever came by again. Had to wait forever for check. The food was fine no complaint there. Didn't much care forthe price of an 18 Oz. Draft. Almost 9 bucks are you kidding me. Anyway would probably go somewhere else. Too bad because it's anice place and good is decent Read more

Delicious pulled pork burger, fries, and garlic parmesan fries. Professional and friendly staff as well. Only dissapointment... easily the portion sizes. Especially when paying $5 to upgrade to lattice fries and only receiving a small basket, and leavingstill a little hungry after a meal and dessert. A perfect score would be had if you got a little more bang for your buck. Read more

We ordered the following through Door Dash; Cheesy Beef Sliders, Nachos, and Chicken Coreon Bleu with fries and caesar salad. My... daughter told me that the burger tasted funny, so I took a closer look and noticed that the inside of her burger wasn't evencooked. The fries were also very under cooked and the nachos had next to no cheese. I called the restaurant and spoke with theon duty Manager. She advised me that she could only offer a credit of the uncooked items. I expressed to her that I only wishedto have a refund of the items mentioned above and that I did not want a credit, as I wasn't going to order delivery from themagain. I offered to bring the food back in to her. She began to laugh at me on the phone and said you are not understandingetc., you can only have a credit. She also expressed that they can't guarantee service when ordering delivery through a 3rdparty(which I found very odd). I told her that I'd understand if the food was cold due to delivery(which it was), but there's noexcuse for burgers being under cooked and that they do have control over that issue. No one orders a burger rare. She told tocall back in morning and to speak with the other Manager. Read more

I went there during a weekday for dinner. It was nice and quiet so the service was quick as the staff were not busy at all. ... The food was made quickly and accurate. The only issue I had was the portion size was quite small and my meal was $39 and Ifound it to be mediocre. Nothing to get excited about really. I'd still recommend it tho. Just not very memorable. Read more

Very very disappointed with the food here and will never order here again. The portion sizes were very small for the amount of... money I paid. I ordered the Parmesan Crusted Chicken Rigatoni which said it came with a ?creamy sauce? there was literally notone drop of sauce. I got boiled pasta (not even salted) with pieces of chicken on top. Not enjoyable at all. My friend orderedthe Lemon Garlic Salmon which was burnt and tasted like charr. Didn?t even taste like salon or lemon and garlic. My familyordered the Mountain Stacked Nachos and it surely was not a mountain. Barely any toppings were on the nachos. Unfortunately, Idid not have a great experience and I was looking forward to eating here. Read more

Visiting Peterborough, sports tournament; recommended to us. Big new place, I counted 12+ modern screens, will put volume on for... playoff games and such, friendly and conscientious staff, great manager. At times can get super busy with group reservations!Large patio for those nice weather days. Read more