Reviews for The Bagel Mill in Petaluma, CA
Good bagels with great chew. Good crispy bacon on the bagel. Great selection of fresh toppings and bagels to choose from (I got... the garlic bagel Bodega Eggs, & Cheese + bacon). The coffee was good and well made. Tasted fresh, not burned. The service wasfriendly and helpful answering my questions about a few items. Read more
Best place in Northern California for bagels. Not only that, they have rotating fresh cream cheese using locally sourced... ingredients (my favorite: summer?s roasted strawberry cream cheese ????). They also make fantastic coffee drinks. Beyond allthat, the staff is awesome, friendly and helpful. Highly recommend. Read more
Nice environment, but I just felt like I was greeted rudely & I've been to many bagel places all over I never had to " call in... for a order". They had plenty of bagels. Personally it reminds me of a upscale bagel spot in the Hamptons that is trying to beto much. Read more
The Sunday ONLY Sticky Buns are to die for! ????????????? Also love the sourdough Cinnamon Raisin bagels with Cinnamon Honey... cream cheese. The texture is perfect! Slight crunch with a toothy bite. Love it! ????Love the Bagel Mill! I feel personallyinvested in their start-up success because their shop is gorgeous, their food is amazing and they have friendly service! ? Read more
The blistered shishito cream cheese is genius. The pesto bagel with cheese baked on top of it is also novel and wonderful. The... vegetables seemed fresh. Coffee was pretty good. Read more
Great bagels with a nice chew. We had the sesame and marble rye ones. Would have liked a bit more crunch on the crust, but... really these are the best bagels I've had in Petaluma. The veggie schmear is really good! Looking forward to trying more menuitems. It's cool they take online orders for pick-up, too. Read more
Lately I've been obsessed with bagels and it looks like the West Coast bagel scene is firing up (according to NYT). So I decided... to check out a local bagel business. I bought beautiful marble rye bagels to take home for the week and tried a whole wheateverything lox bagel with a latte. I love supporting local businesses and I hope you give this place a try. Read more
Great spot. Had a quick coffee here which was quite good. My friends had other drinks which they loved as well, and praised the... bagel they got. Good atmosphere. No complaints really - wouldn?t hesitate to stop by again. Read more