Reviews for Smitty McMusselman's Pub & Grub in Peru, IN
This place looked nice, I scouted it because I planned to eat and buy beer here. I visited this place several times to buy a cup... of coffee. People seemed fine and there was never a problem. I brought another customer in with me and we both ordered a cup ofcoffee. We did not tip because the 3 dollar coffee tasted badly. The next couple of weeks we came in we were actually rejectedservice because we did not tip for a horrible cup of 3 dollar coffee. The waitress harbored this for two weeks and waited for usto come in to say this. This is the worst service I have ever had, avoid this place like a plague. Its no wonder I didn?t tipwith service like this. Even on good days when it is dead the waitress rarely would come around. Try Dillinger?s instead, theyhave great food, great service and I always tip there because they actually work for it. Smittys is old and outdated and veryawkward to get through if and when they actually have people in there because of its tiny space. Parking can be a nightmare, itsbetter to just walk and the waitress can be rude and decline service altogether if she does not receive a tip the way she wantsit. If you choose to brave this bar avoid the waitress with dark hair, pigtails and short height. She drives customers away andleaves a bad taste in your mouth literally, she gets no tip you get no service. Take a tip from me and just avoid this placethere far better bars in Peru. Read more
Parking was limited and many park along the shoulder of the road, but plenty of tables inside. Typical pub menu, not exciting... but solid and well prepared. Specials were all u can eat fish Sat., tenderloin (not on regular menu) one night. Chicken Pot Piesoup was good. Prices were reasonable, service was very good. This was my first trip but I'd go back. Read more
Great food and atmosphere! Waitress/bartender was not too friendly at first throwing the menus and silverware down on our table!... This was our first time there! Read more
We picked this place on our trip. Just randomly. Thank goodness we did! We love it. Our server Lucy was happy to help us and... checked on us enough. My bf had drunken chicken and enjoyed it. I went with turkey Manhattan. Happy I did. 2 kids enjoyednachos. One of them had the Ruben and said it was good. The smallest had chicken tenders and fries. I never know if he likes hisfood or not but I'm guessing he did. Read more
Great food,great service, good prices
We totally enjoyed our dinner. The burger was cooked to perfection, & their pulled pork was good.
Authentic atmosphere. There was a few Irish options. The bangers and mash was solid. The need stew had great flavor but only had... two pieces of beef, hence the 4 stars. Hey had a ham and cheese dish was was awesome. The Brussels sprouts and bacon was a greatappetizer. Also they didn't have any Amish our unfortunately. Read more
Great quality food, great beer/cocktail menu. Really enjoyed having Kynedi as our bartender! Also the waitresses Maggie and... Brooke were very friendly and always smiling. Will definitely be back!! Glad there?s a place in Peru my husband and I can feelat home at. Read more