Reviews for Casey's in Peoria, IL
DISGUSTING KITCHEN!! They have flies and gnats literally everywhere. Employees don't follow health and safety protocols at all,... they use expired products for their "fresh food", dishes are reused repeatedly and not washed. To top it all off, their kitchenemployees including management DO NOT have a SIMPLE FOOD HANDLERS LICENSE. Basically, this place is great if you're interestedin purchasing an overpriced food related illness. Save yourselves please Read more
I ordered online tonight for delivery. It kept showing new drivers with estimated time of delivery and then would just... disappear. This problem is on Door Dash since they deliver for this store. However, I didn't get a phone call from Casey's and Itried to call with no answer. Now I have no pizza or breadsticks and I have to go to the store tomorrow to get a refund forproduct never delivered. Horrible service on both parts. Read more
Listen, I get it, Casey?s is a gas station. People would say gas station pizza is nasty but this isn?t any ole gas station... pizza. It?s made to order and cooked in a pizza oven. I was skeptical but totally impressed! I would eat this pizza over any bigchain pizza. Only gave four stars because as a former gas station employee...the place wasn?t the cleanest. But the staff washelpful and friendly and shelves were fully stocked! Read more
For a gas station, this place is pretty good. Employees are nice and well trained. Gas prices are usually some of the best in... town. Pizza is awesome. Jeff is a great manager. They better keep him around. Read more
We ordered a pizza and wings for delivery and ended up only getting half the order of wings. So i called them to let them know... and the cook said he did forget to make the second order but there was nothing he could do. So I asked to speak with a managerhe said there wasn't one there. He was very rude about it so I called the next day to speak with the manager to tell them aboutmy exsperience with there employee. The manager apoligized and took my number and said she was going to talk to him and callme back but she never did. So I will never use this store again i will just use another one. Read more
Placed an order for two large pizzas, 1 pep 1 sausage and an order of 20 wings. The cook was on break so I returned about 40... minutes later. Only to have 1 pizza with both toppings an no wings. The cook was on another break smoking this time and wouldn'tcome in for the cashier. I was going to purchase just the 1 pizza because it was 7 at night and I needed to get home after along day of working and had kids to feed, but no discount was even offered for the pizza they messed up on. Horrible customerservice and I will not be returning for my usual gas and morning coffee to your location anymore. Read more
Editing from original posting below... We have ordered twice since original post. These last two pizzas were yuck, the cheese... isn't acting cheesy but its chewy now. Like they've changed their cheese to something else, idk what. Very disappointed, it wasinitially the best pizza, but now its not even close. One more chance, that's all they get. Oh, and this last time we wantedsome donuts but there were flies in the case, yucky. Ordered a supreme, and totally changed the toppings while ordering itonline. Picked it up, the clerk confirmed all the changes at p/u and it was PERFECT!!! The pizza was fantastic. We preferCasey's by far over Pizza Hut and Papa Johns. It has the perfect amount of toppings. If you rip off ten carton tags and hangonto them you can get a free pizza. They have a summer giveaway promotion going on too. Read more
Fix your hours if your not open til 11pm don't have it listed didn't drive out of my way to get here 30 mins before to get... turned away bad business Read more