Reviews for The Sicilian Butcher Peoria in Peoria, AZ

At first we were bummed because we called ahead and we were told we couldn't get a reservation. We had 12 people so we figured... there was no way we would get a table if we were just walk in guests later that evening. We were celebrating my grandmothersbirthday and wanted it to be special. We decided to give it a try and went to the restaurant at 10 minutes to 5. We got seatedalmost immediately! Our server (Keith I believe?) was great. Very sweet and attentive. The food was amazing, the desserts wereeven better! I got a 'statue of David' coctail and it came in a cool cup, haha. The location is beautiful as well with a niceindoor and outdoor area. The bathrooms were even beautiful. Definitely recommend stopping by! ???? Read more

We had a wonderful business lunch here. Everyone enjoyed their meal and Dom (the manager) was very welcoming! Our server was... great and even brought out samplings of the cannolli filling for one of the guest to try. If I lived in Phoenix this woulddefinitely be one of my go-to spots! Read more

Such an unique place! What a refresher after all these cliche chain restaurants everywhere. They have a sophisticated interior... and exterior design with a refreshing array of menu options. The outdoor setting has a covered patio with misters andartificial turf. Their attention to detail inside is fun and eventful. It's also great that they have a bakery on site fordesert as well. We had a great time for our anniversary and the flavor of the food was amazing. The Almond Pesto Pasta is myfavorite! Read more

Amazing experience. We were seated within 15 minutes on the weekend. Not bad! As you can see we ordered a variety of food and... enjoyed every minute of it. The food is cooked to perfection & they add amazing flavors to each dish. Highly recommend stoppingby so you can share the experience. Read more

Nice first experience. I have to say the flavors of some meatballs and sauces were not to our liking, especially the lamb... meatball with nutmeg. I wasn't ready to eat an eggnog meatball, but that's just me. Everything was perfectly cooked, andpresented well. Bread and beet salad with figs was excelent. Very clean, friendly staff, nice easy menu. Random thought- some ofour plates were huge, like the salad plate. Nice amount of food but I wouldn't have missed some of it if it were smaller and fiton a smaller plate. Could be a fun resturant to take friends to. Read more

We had a wonderful family dinner out on the patio. It was cool outside, but they turned the heater up, and it was comfortable. ... The pasta and meatballs were very good. The desserts are wonderful. They melt in your mouth. Overall, it was a great night. Iwould recommend this restaurant! Read more

Enjoyed the open bar to the outside. Weather was perfect. We sat at the bar and the bartender was friendly and attentive. Food... was delicious. Our dishes came straight from the oven. The bartender offered fresh grated cheese for our dish. We took homeleftovers because the portions were a lot. Read more

We went early evening and it was fairly busy. We ended up snagging some seats at the bar and were immediately greeted by the... bartender. She was great and offered her advice on the drink menu. I ordered the recommended Italiano cocktail, which was agreat choice. We ordered some meatballs and calamari for an appetizer and we found them both to be quite good. For dinner I hadthe short rib canneloni and it was quite good as well. I would definitely recommend this place and look forward to returning. Read more