Reviews for Peg Leg Pete's in Pensacola Beach, FL
Peg Leg Pete's came highly recommended on our travels and the food definitely did not disappoint! First thing though, do not be... dissuaded by the hostesses, they are definitely not a representation of the remaining staff or experience. Management shouldprobably pay a bit more attention to the first impression they are giving the restaurant! That being said, once seated,everything is fabulous! Chandra was super friendly, laughed with us many times and had us laughing plenty!! She was veryattentive and provided great service, great enough that we came back the next day, sadly she was off that day! The food wasphenomenal! We started with the Baked Oyster Sampler and then shared the recommended Stuffed Shrimp dinner. The sampler broughtus back the next day for another platter, they were that good!! The second visit, hubby had the red beans and rice which ishuge, and I had a bowl of chowder which is loaded and delicious! Ryan was our server on our second visit and he was just asfriendly as Chandra was on the first visit! Great food, great service (other than hostess), we will definitely recommend andreturn! Read more
Went early to get takeout. If there is a wait list, they suspend any new takeout orders. Very popular place and great seafood!... We had the Grouper Nuggets and the Seafood Chowder. Both were fantastic. The Chowder is made with fresh grouper and is sooogood! The Grouper Nuggets were good sized Nuggets and were cooked perfectly. Read more
Beware of a wait time during peak hours. Once you get on the wait list you'll be able to view your wait time on Yelp, and you... can leave and come back as they'll save your table for 5 minutes. The wait staff is incredible, Matt was our server and he wasattentive. The food was delicious, snow crab legs were sweet and not overcooked. The atmosphere is pirate themed and clean. Iwould recommend coming here to eat some seafood, oysters, and Cajun style food. Their gift shop is cute, and they also have anonline store. There is a bar underneath but I did not check it out. Read more
My fiancee and I enjoyed our first visit to this place for dinner the other night - there was about an hour wait, so be prepared... for that, but we just grabbed a drink and enjoy the dock and views (and each others company) until it was our turn. Honestly,the wait is EVERY BIT worth it -- the food was outta this world delicious and very well priced!! Service was amazing as well -wish I could remember the gal who took great care of us - I do know she had cool green hair and was so super nice! We willdefinitely be back when we're in Pensacola!! Read more
Stopped by Peg Leg Pete's for lunch. This place is packed so be prepared to wait! We waited 45 minutes and were not... disappointed. The Cajun shrimp and the stuffed shrimp were are favorite items that we ate. The Po' Boy was good but a little dryit could have used more sauce. The Cajun shrimp wrap was good; but, could also have used a little more sauce. The fried seafoodcombo was huge!! The portions are large so bring your appetite. The atmosphere is lively. Our server was okay, but, wasnonexistent after we got our meals so we never got drink refills. Read more
My first time visiting Pensacola Beach and was told this was the place to go. They were not wrong. Order the fried calamari for... an appetizer and the fried shrimp and grouper plate with baby potatoes and red beans and rice. Everything was amazing. Servicewas great as well. Read more
The experience was excellent. I had the fish chowder and gumbo. My first time ever trying fish chowder and it was amazing. The... gumbo was a little watery for my liking (but I'm from New Orleans and I'm pitting their gumbo against my grandma's). The gumbowas file and the flavor was really good. I also had the grouper balls, they were really good. The server was amazing, didn'twrite anything down, and he didn't get one order wrong. Read more
Been on the island two days and each night, we?ve chosen to eat here. Seafood was great (mixed platter), raw oysters great,... people are responsive and friendly. Enjoyed the girls serving drinks at the bar, they were nice as well. Overall great space toeat and nice atmosphere. Laid back in December at least. Read more