Reviews for Lost Pizza Co. in Pensacola, FL
These photos are from past visits and not my most recent visit. But, they were good pies too. I've been to Lost Pizza several... times and have always enjoyed it. We like their wings, particularly the jerk flavor. We really like their tamales. My wife likestheir taco pie or we get the one with artichokes on the thin crust. Left on my own, I go with pepperoni or the loaded pies onthe thicker crusts. They've got a few local beers on tap too. Always had friendly service. Read more
I don't venture to this side of town too often but have always wanted to try the pizza here. I was not disappointed by any... means. The menus were right there as you walk in, so we were able to grab one and have our order ready by the time we got to thecounter. I enjoy being able to choose where you want to eat, so we got a nice window booth. The food came out timely and inorder since we had an appetizer first. The Pit Boss signature pizza was a good go to for the first visit and I'm looking forwardto trying the others! Read more
Yummy pizza and food. Wings are award winning though? It was pretty good wings to me but nothing crazy. The angel hair gets... soggy very fast but that?s most of their pasta options. The Greek salad was delicious though. Overall a great pizza place! Read more
Great pizza and atmosphere. Thick pan style and a crispy thin crust. They also have a really nice.gluten free cauliflower... crust pie. Read more
11-13-2021: first time here - ordered to go a medium taco pie with extra meat. I got the thin crust. Good flavor and comes with... salsa and sour cream (they were out of sour cream). 5-20-2023: Friday early evening dinner - first time dining inside. My wifeand I struggle with wanting to see a menu -due to the line we could not see the wall menu and no paper menus were anyway nearthe door; so that our thoughts could be ready once at the cash register. Not an easy in and out main door. I ordered the fat boythink crust pizza which is like a cheeseburger type (not much meat was my only issue) but tasted good. My wife ordered a specialpizza: pesto tomato mushroom cheese thick crust: she really like hers. We also ordered the olive bread which was excellent. Acouple of fountain drinks and a few minutes they brought the food which was very fresh. I think with a few little changescustomer focus could be improved. Not a fan of wobble tables or the floor. They do offer a outside eating area which lookedinviting. Read more
I ordered online. It was about a 45 min wait which was fine because I had other things to do first. The website was easy to... order from. I've had problems with other websites. The pizza was hot and ready to go when I arrived. The staff was friendly andaccommodating. I had ordered a thick crust with extra cheese and banana peppers. The crust was soft but not doughy. The crustwas good but very very thick. I like a decent amount of sauce to compensate for the thickness of the crust but there was only athin layer of sauce. Maybe I needed to order extra sauce but I've never done that before. The cheese was melted to perfection and the banana peppers were browned on top and sooo good. I will try the thin crust next time or maybe they just haveregular.If I order a thick crust again, I will order extra sauce or have sauce to dip it in , but that's just me. Read more
My family and I decided to try out this place after hearing about from some friend. The atmosphere was awesome. I loved the... decorations and such. We weren?t greeted when we walked in and we had zero idea as to where to sit and such. We didn?t get menusfor a bit. I?m assuming because of short staffed, or at least I hope so. The food was incredibly good but WAY over priced. Icould get the same pizza and quality at other places for cheaper. I may give this place another try Read more
First time visit and wasn?t really impressed. We ordered the olive bread which was good but did not have much olive toppings to... be called olive bread, cheese bread with olives would be more accurate. We also had the kujo pie, thick crust. Crust reminded meof Pizza Hut pan pizza from back in the day. The crust had a very distinct beer/alcohol taste from fermentation which wasn?tunpleasant. The pie assembler sucked because you can see most of the toppings are on one side of the pie. Pies are good size sowe took half a pie home. Place seems like a meeting place for families with kids after sporting events. It?s got an ice creamparlor attached and a game room. Small bar for adult beverages. If your looking for a place enjoy a pie and a conversation withfriends this ain?t it unless you like to yell. But if your looking for a place to take the kids , this is a place worth lookingat. Read more