Reviews for Pelham Pizza in Village of Pelham, NY
Great pizza, just how I remembered prior to covid. Plenty of staff to keep food flowing out the door. My family enjoyed the pie... I brought home...I enjoyed the price I paid????. It was a little less than what I would've paid somewhere closer to home. Protip, bring someone with you... unfortunately they are limited to street parking. At night it can be a little difficult to get aconvenient spot and the police presence (on the weekend nights) can be felt. You don't want to double park. I'm dying to go backto try the pasta. Read more
I don?t know what?s better here the food or the staff. Both are top notch. That was hands down the best Buffalo chicken slice... I?ve ever had and the crust was perfect for it. Sturdy enough to support all that chicken but not too thick. I also got achicken roll that I couldn?t eat because the slice was so filling. I did have 2 bites of it before I wrapped it up to go and itwas sooooooo good. I?m glad I had to catch a train otherwise I probably would have stuffed myself with it. The prices weregreat, too. Perfect old school pizzeria. I?m now motivated to leave for work a little bit earlier so I can come here. Read more
I've been coming here to Pelham Pizza for over 20yrs. and without a doubt the best Pizza in the area. The staff are amazing very... neighborly and the food is awesome. Family friendly and always consistent with their quality of food and service. All my kidsknow they can't miss their take out night with Pelham Pizza. Read more
For the serious pizza lovers! They have pizza like everywhere else as cheese, buffalo,margarita etc but you should try the... rest?they have amazing flavors I never seen before . The crust so yummy! The ricotta what they use, it drives me crazy! Dailysoups ,least 5 -6 you can choose from! Pizza place very busy hard to find a table just be patient, you will see worth for thewait! Very friendly people who works so hard the front and back in the kitchen, to serves the best quality pizza on your andmine table! Sorry I couldn?t wait first we took the bites after I did the pictures.. Read more
Good customer service! Great Pizza!
Been a customer for 10+ years. This place never lets me down. Always treated like family when i dine in. These new pepperoni/... jalapeño slices are insane. Read more
One word, DELICIOUS!!! This place is a gem! The environment is friendly and family orientated. At first walking in, I thought it... was just all pizzas. Don't get me wrong, the variety of pizzas offered is great but when I looked to the left and saw wine,fried calamari, soups being served at the table, I quickly realized that this isn't just some regular pizza spot. Stop in, havea sit, and grab something good from the menu. Great for family night out where parents can have a grown up meal and the kids canenjoy a slice! Read more
Food quality more like an upscale restaurant rather than a pizza place. A little busy and noisy but worth the trip. Great... Sicilian slices and great dinner choices. Prices went up recently like every other place but not outrageous Read more