Reviews for Amici’s Pizza & Restaurant in Peekskill, NY

Car pizza was once about the best around; Then they sold. Then it was awful; Now it's quite good again. Haven't sat down here in... years so don't know about that end of things. It certainly looks very good from the pictures and reviews. Read more

It's a dope spot. And the food on top of Kelz, and Andi is a experience that everyone should have!!!????????????????. Just a... little add on. The sweets are from Arthur Ash in the Bronx, and the garlic knots are ba banging. They have a dining room and aatmosphere of romance ????. Come check it out Read more

Normally I don't write reviews, but for this establishment it is necessary. The pizzeria has a gorgeous layout and a fantastic... staff. Everything on the menu is great. Everything from the pizza to the wraps to the pasta is a 10/10. I make the trip herefrom Yonkers for catering orders, my family loves it. I heartily suggest dropping over and treating yourself to some fantasticcuisine and service. Read more

So I ordered delivery from here and was so-so. I ordered spaghetti & meatballs, chicken francese and a side of broccoli rabe.... The spaghetti & meatball was pretty decent the sauce needs a little salt but overall a solid 7 on the classic dish. But thechicken francese was terrible. The chicken wasn't soft and it wasn't lemony zest just all butter or margarine. The broccoli rabewas the worst, it wasn't cooked enough to where the garlic tasted raw. I later recooked the rabe and it tasted good but thisshouldn't be the case when you pay $10 for a side. I hate giving 3 stars so I would eat here again to confirm the score. 60/100 Read more

It?s been awhile since I?ve eaten here like almost 3 years after a conflict with the second owner. Well new ownership has... arrived once again. Food I still no comparison to the original owners. I say it has gotten a bit better since the second owner,but not by much. Starting I got the chicken roll which was a bit pricey about $9.50 with a little bit of peppers it tastedbland and sharped more like burrito. Also, the garlic knots wasn?t crispy at all even after 10 minutes. Tasted like old stalebread. Also, two slices, one pepperoni and one sausage, they were paper thin I accidentally bit my tongue. No moist crust atall. Also, got 2 cannolis and a 20oz coke which were alright nothing to complain about, extra star there. Also, the bill cameto $33.35 with credit cards charges and tips. Not worth it at all. No good pizzerias here in Peekskill / Cortlandt anymore haveto get pizza at Brooklyn when I?m there sad how a local pizza place drops so much after the first owner. Read more

Great food, ambiance and service. The pizza is on top level. Tonight i felt like eating light and boy the grilled Chicken Cesar... wrap excellent almost as if they just got the lettuce from their garden. Glad they are here and going strong. Read more

Very good Italian food. It's a little to cold inside. They should regulate the temperature, sometimes.

My new construction project just started next to here. I got their chicken Parm and pepperoni pizza and tastes great! Been going... there multiple times by now and won?t be going anywhere else for the time being. Would probably be gaining a few pounds after awhile, but who cares the food taste great! Sincerely, Atrin H Read more