Reviews for Plum Tomatoes Brick Oven Pizza in Peabody, MA
Came in yesterday and it was my first time ever, order a small pepperoni pizza and I gotta say it was better than amazing, I... wish i could give them 10 stars, the pizza it self was better then most places I?ve ever been to, I also had a accident the daybefore at work in which I needed my pizza to be cut into squares and when I asked they didn?t it with out no questions asked,even when waiting on my pizzas the two gentleman ( Im so sorry I forgot your guy?s name already) were friendly with everycustomer that came in and actually seem like they both wanted to be there and were happy to be working, even when i came in Iwas welcome with smiles and etc? the two guys in the kitchen definitely know what there doing, I will definitely come back tothis place again, Thank you guys for making my first experience the best!! Read more
The signature plum pizza is to die for. Usually they have the ripe cherry tomatoes with rich flavors. It does not need... sauce. But be specific because or not they'll give you a regular pizza with sauce and regular tomatoes. Don't get that. Read more
Pizza isn?t amazing but it?s not bad. There sandwiches are amazing though and very friendly team in there
Grabbed a large cheese pizza, Buffalo pizza extra blue cheese and a meatball calzone. Copped the 5% discount for paying with... cash and enjoyed the food. Helpful staff, clean spot and quick with the goods?? will definitely go back! Read more
Beyond delicious pizza! My fiance and I were passing by on an East Coast road trip on our way back to NY and we were craving... local hole-in-the-wall pizza. We ordered the Melanzane which was garlicky and had fried eggplant on top and it hit the spot.Were so happy to have stopped by. Very good food and definitely recommend! Read more
This place makes some very good pizza! I can't believe this was our first visit and they've been here 16 years. The cheese pizza... was perfect! Crispy, but dry crust with a tasty sauce and just the right amount of cheese! The whole small pizza was loaded withveggies and just so good the next day! Read more
Picked up two pizzas tonight, a Margherita and a Kitchen Sink. The pizzas are excellent, especially for someone who loves thin,... crispy crust pizza. The Margherita pizza had fresh mozzarella and basil and the fresh tomato sauce was excellent. I addedartichoke hearts....YUM!! The Kitchen Sink is basically a meat lovers with peppers, onions and mushrooms added. We're talkingWHOLE STRIPS OF BACON HERE!!. This pizza was excellent too. There was only one issue. The bottom crusts on both pizzas weresoggy and floppy. They were properly cooked so I'm not sure why they were so soggy. The edge was crispy and delicious though. Ifthey could figure out some way to fix the sogginess, their pizza would be 5 star easily. Oh, and on Mon and Tues the pizzas arebuy one get one half off!!! Read more
Best meatballs next to my mom?s. Sauce is perfect, not too sweet or too spicy/salty. Food is fresh and delicious. Service is... great. I love their meatball sub with mozzarella but their pizza is awesome too. Read more