Reviews for Valentino‘s Pizzeria & Restaurant in Patchogue, NY

My original review is from a month ago visit in which I reported incident to both waitress and owner. I haven?t returned since.... If changes have been made especially to dining area I have no knowledge. If it has been cleaned, sanitized and roach free withnew take over I will consider returning. Read more

Beware....The only good thing I can say was that the waitress was very nice. After ordering food noticed roaches crawling... around. When I informed waitress she said they were aware of issue. She said they had cleaned restaurant themselves since,owner couldn't afford professional cleaners. When speaking to the owner regarding roach issue the pizza boxes he was holdingroaches were going into them as well. They need to rip out the dirty carpet along with booths. They need professional cleaningalong with exterminator to bomb the place. Read more

Absolutely disgusting! Soggy dough horrible sauce that quite honestly tasted really weird. Ordered a chicken parm slice chicken... was rubbery slice fell apart. Nobody was wearing gloves and the man behind the counter was standing outside the door smokingthen came back in and went back behind the counter helping customers with washing his hands!! Read more

The place was closed for about a month or so after the former owners sold their business....not sure what was done in the... interim because I don?t notice anything decor wise that is different. There are no napkins anywhere to be found in the frontdining area so bring your own if you go! I suppose that's one difference. The pizza is okay, nothing to get excited about. Notas good as the prior owner's pizza. I hate writing negative reviews but I tried twice to see if I was going to like the changeand I'm not impressed. My first visit in the beginning of August was ruined by the young cashier who wouldn't stoptalking.......to me, every customer, just non stop the whole time. He must watch a lot of Soprano reruns because he asked metwice, "how's the family?". I've never met this guy and it was annoying and stereotypical. He was doing it to everyone thatwalled in. My second visit was two days ago and it was much quieter (no patronizing cashier guy) but the pizza was a bit boring.I might go back if I'm starving on my way home from work but if I'm in the mood for good pizza, I'll go elsewhere, maybeDonatina's further down by Main Street or even the place by Chachama Grill. Read more

Was looking forward to trying this pizzeria after the renaming, unfortunately this may have been some of the worst pizza I?ve... had in a long time. The pizza was absolutely flavorless despite having meatball and sausage toppings. The crust was way toocrispy and the sauce was as flavorless as the cheese and meat toppings. Read more

Not what it used to be at all :( crust is barely browned, sauce is very sweet, pinwheel had next to no cheese.

I ordered on Uber eats and got delivery. I got wings, mozzarella sticks and a meatball parmigiana hero. The wings and mozzarella... sticks were okay but the hero was really not good. I don?t think I?ve ever had an issue with a meatball parm from a pizza placebut this was really bad. It was dry and didn?t have a good flavor. I would not order from here again. Read more

Everyone has an opinion about pizza and bagels right! ???? It's interesting that most of the bad feedback is within the past... year. Something change? I have to agree with some, I'm sorry. I hope the owners read thru these, it's a nice place. - soggypizza, that's the pile that slid off the soggy base in the photo. - not a lot of taste ( here again, one dudes opinion) - womanbehind the counter is less then approachable, tries to talk to multiple customers at once and things get lost in mix and Idislike being called "hon"???? There busy with seemingly plenty of regulars anyway.. Read more