Reviews for Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe in Patchogue, NY
I was a little disappointed because it was my first time there. We ordered the Detroit style pizza. The flavor was good but it... was extremely salty. Almost to the point of not being edible. Garlic knots were a little bland. I like to see chunks of garlicon my knots but these did not have that. However the service was great and the cannolis were good. I'll try them again. But nexttime I'm going to request no added salt....if that's possible. If my next experience is better i will give more stars on myreview. Read more
It's good, but not standout on LI Regular slice: 3.5 stars, very thin crust Garlic knots: 4 stars, perfect amount of garlic,... bread not quite soft enough Specialty slices: 2.5 a bit overcooked and crunchy. Might be a plus if you like that. Meat onbuffalo slide and pulled pork was dried out. Read more
Drove 45 minutes for this pizza. The Detroit style pizza did not disappoint. Highly recommend.
It's OK, thought it was pricey for the small pieces of pizza . Just received a response from the " owner" which said Thank you... , although I appreciate the quick response they didn't address one of my concerns. 2 small pieces of Sicilian style pizza eachslice was like half the size of a regular Sicilian slice available at any pizzeria and a regular slice with broccoli 15.00dollars I think that's way overpriced however to receive a response of Thank you left me to believe review wasn't even read !!If you're going to respond clearly you should read the review or don't bother. Thanks . Edit I responded to response from owneron my original review. Read more
Family and I really enjoyed this place during a visit to the area. The place we clean, service was fast AND friendly and the... food was really good. We have a few different pizzas and they were all good. The cheese stuffed knots were all good. I woulddefinitely recommend it! Read more
Great place! Stopped in last night on the fly with my wife and sat at the counter near the pizza oven. Watched our food get made... and it was delicious. But this was the best part...an order comes in and the pizza chef starts working his magic and for fun Itimed him. 5 pies of various types prepped in 3min 59sec, into the oven and while cooking he was getting the boxes ready andadding wood to the fire, 5 pies out of the oven in 3min 29sec. The guy is a machine...the back of his shirt says it all! Read more
Very good pizza. Different, tasty. Detroit style, wood oven style, traditional style, you name it, they make it. Good beer on... tap, nice little bar. Stop in for a quick bite, you will enjoy it. It's part of Patchogue Village but off to the side. Worth thevisit Read more
Very disappointed in this experience. As a pizza lover, who views pizza as its own ?food group?, this is my worst experience in... years. The counter person was useless to a first time customer who shared it was the first time to visit. She treated me as abother, no explanation of the menu or even the process for ordering for dine in or take out Asked for a pepperoni and mushroompizza and she just stared at me, then when I asked how large that would be, she said 16 inch pie, I told her that was too bigfor one pizza, then she said you wanted a Neapolitan size and pointed to a menu above my head. There was a mushroom pizzalisted, asked if I could get pepperoni added, she blankly stared at me. Pizza was brought to me, no plate, table service, or myDiet Coke. Had to go back to counter to get my Diet Coke, no check back from the waiter. Pizza was cold, and lacked flavor. Iare two slices and left the rest of the pie. Not a place I would recommend. Read more