Reviews for P.Jay's Pizza in Parma, OH
For the price, I was given huge portions and the service was great. I will go there again and I recommend them! The apple pizza... was really really good. Read more
I enjoy their thick crust pizza however they don't bake the bottom long enough it tends to be soggy. I think if they baked it... about 5 minutes longer it would be a great pizza. Read more
Order a pizza for my family at 4:45pm was told 55 min No problem. 610p no pizza.My wife calls just check on our order was told... it was on its way. 625p I call and was told sorry we never made it. Then was hung up on. Trash. Read more
Got the fries, pizza, and chicken parm. The chicken parm is just a Walmart chicken patty with jar sauce. And the pizza was... disappointing as were the fries. Read more
Easy online ordering, ample parking, friendly staff, order prepared quickly and the pizza super delicious! Glad to have P Jay's... near me! They do Bacon pizza right! A++ Read more
I was just delivered the worst pizza I've ever had in my life from P.Jays. It was a speciality pizza called Sicilian Sausage. ... When you bake a pizza with sausage on it, the grease will exit the sausage, and filter down to the crust. Imagine a pizza crustfilled with uncooked sausage and what would happen. And that's exactly what I got. A grease laden crust so wet, and disgusting,you could actually pick up a piece and watch grease drip from it. Never ever again. Read more
Used to love this place, would get it 1 or 2 times a week, the past few months it has been very inconsistent and either very... good, or just not edible. Tried ordering tonight at 8:50 (they close at 930), to someone picking the phone up and hanging upimmediately, then not picking up the phone at all the next 2 times i call. Sad to say i will not be back. Plenty of other pizzajoints around town to eat at. Read more
1st time ordering their pizza, and it was a bit more expensive to what I'm used to paying. However, the food was delicious.... Everything was great. We had large pizza, salad, and cheese garlic bread. All items were perfe t Read more