Reviews for Sal's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Palmyra, VA

Solid place, but very average food. Wonderful waitress, but she was not very present. For example, no refills on coffee... offered. Long wait at register to pay... For was veal marsala. It was watery, more like soggy breaded slices insoup. Staffing is tight, so that's probably the reason. Read more

Visiting from New Jersey which I consider to be the pizza capital of the US. This is some of the best pizza I?ve had in years.... Crisp yet doughy and light. Great tasting sauce and incredible service. 10/10 Read more

Sal's was such a nice surprise! We loved this little gem tucked into Lake Monticello. The food is delicious and the server was... friendly and fun. My husband and I are now regulars! Read more

Great local restaurant with a comprehensive menu. Food was tasty, and the service (Patrick) was terrific. We?ll be back!

There are a lot of Sal?s Italian restaurants in the regional Virginia area and this is another one. I got dinners to go but got... a good look at the ambiance, very local. Food is good. Well put together. Pizza rolls very good. Chicken parm ok. Good comfortfood when you don?t want to cook. Not recommended for a special night out. Read more

Absolutely phenomenal food!! Came here with 6 family members and all of us loved our food! I had the Seafood Fettuccine and it... was, hands down, the best I?ve ever had. The wine was also fantastic! Renee was very nice and very attentive. We never had towait for anything. We will absolutely eat here again!! Read more

We were in from out of town and our friends wanted us to eat here. We were not disappointed. My wife had eggplant parmesan and I... had sausage with peppers. Both were good. The garlic knots that came with the meals was good as well. We shared a bottle of wineand had a good time. The only negative was my Caesar salad had no dressing on it. Read more

New York meal in small town Palmyra. Being from Brooklyn, New York, I was always accustomed the having a large choice of... outstanding Italian restaurants within a short distance. One of the things I miss the most about NY is the variety. In centralVirginia, that variety is just not there. Sal's has been open for awhile now but until tonight, we just had the pizza andheroes for takeout. (Both are excellent). Celebrating a special occasion tonight, my wife selected dinner at Sal's. We each hada cocktail to start off the meal, followed by a house salad that came with our dinners. We each ordered the Trio Pasta, which isLasagna, Manicotti and Stuffed Shell. Added a side of meatballs to complete the meal I was really in the mood for the shellsbut changed my mind in order to sample a variety. Each part was covered with mozzarella, always a plus in my book. The trio wasoutstanding. If you asked me to pick a favorite I don't think I could. The food was delicious. The service was excellent, (andthey were busy, too). The atmosphere very peaceful. An excellent restaurant in any setting, in small town Palmyra, a gold mine. Read more