Reviews for Three Brothers New York Pizza in Palm Harbor, FL

We so wanted this to be good. For a couple of reasons, the pricing is good. It is very local to us. The owners/management are... super friendly and nice. however, after ordering a couple of times, we just realize that the crust is just simply soggy and notcrispy. I am from NY and it is just weird to me. We tried to take the pie to go and put in our oven, but the crust on thebottom did not get crispy. It remained soggy. The rest of the pizza was great. Cheese and sauce were workable. This is sounfortunately. If you do not mind the pizza being soggy on the bottom dough, then this place will work out for you. I tried. Read more

As I continue to search for real quality pizza in Tampa, Three Brothers is definitely one of the top I have found. I called in... the order and when I arrived, while very busy, my order was ready for pick up. The pizza is very good with a nice crust, sauceis good and the right amount of cheese. I would highly recommend Three Brothers Pizza. Read more

The pizza is really good, no question. You just have to deal with the staff, who clearly don't give a s&^%. Called to place an... order, repeated the order to the person, went to pick up and confirmed the order TWICE as I made the payment - and they stillscrewed up. Then they speak to the "manager" who was even less interested. I just left. Last time I picked up, another customercomplained why the pizza was taking so long, and she was told...we can cancel the order and you can leave if you wish. Overall,seems like they brought the authentic northeast US pizza to Florida and the attitude to match. Just be courteous, it's reallynot that hard. Read more

Excellent pizza, great tasting sausage. Wings were delicious as well

The pizza here is great. I typically include instructions for a "well done" bake because otherwise I never get a crispy crusty... (even when I do, it's 50/50 at best). I did not include those instructions when I ordered here tonight, but the crusty wascrispy. That's so rare that I had to leave a review. The marinara is also excellent, so I recommended getting some with thepizza. Read more

The pizza here is great. I typically include instructions for a "well done" bake because otherwise I never get a crispy crusty... (even when I do, it's 50/50 at best). I did not include those instructions when I ordered here tonight, but the crusty wascrispy. That's so rare that I had to leave a review. The marinara is also excellent, so I recommended getting some with thepizza. Read more

One word for this place: amazing! Today was $9.99 for a large pie, amazing deal. The pizza is amazing and you can tell... everything is freshly made. We got a large cheese pizza with bacon and mozzarella sticks. Everything was hot and fresh out ofthe oven. The cashier was super sweet and made sure we were okay throughout the visit. Definitely a hole in the wall place, butI?m not sure why people were complaining about cleanliness. All the tables were clean and there wasn?t even any trash on thefloor. Definitely a little small on the inside but you can always bring your pizza home to eat! I will definitely be coming backas I?m super excited to try other types of pizzas and other foods from the menu. Highly recommend!! Also, the tool they had forthe pizza is absolutely genius and helped with actually getting a slice instead of just kinda flopping the pizza all over andgetting sauce everywhere lol. Read more

One word for this place: amazing! Today was $9.99 for a large pie, amazing deal. The pizza is amazing and you can tell... everything is freshly made. We got a large cheese pizza with bacon and mozzarella sticks. Everything was hot and fresh out ofthe oven. The cashier was super sweet and made sure we were okay throughout the visit. Definitely a hole in the wall place, butI?m not sure why people were complaining about cleanliness. All the tables were clean and there wasn?t even any trash on thefloor. Definitely a little small on the inside but you can always bring your pizza home to eat! I will definitely be coming backas I?m super excited to try other types of pizzas and other foods from the menu. Highly recommend!! Also, the tool they had forthe pizza is absolutely genius and helped with actually getting a slice instead of just kinda flopping the pizza all over andgetting sauce everywhere lol. Read more

Edited: Meal wasn?t perfect, but Keith from Three Brothers went out of his way to make it right. Will definitely be ordering... again! Garlic knots and pear salad were both great. The garlic knots were hot and fresh. Delivery was on time. Pizza flavor wasgood. Read more

Edited: Meal wasn?t perfect, but Keith from Three Brothers went out of his way to make it right. Will definitely be ordering... again! Garlic knots and pear salad were both great. The garlic knots were hot and fresh. Delivery was on time. Pizza flavor wasgood. Read more

If you like cheese and ingredients well dispersed, don't go here. All crust and lacking cheese for more than 1" (2"mostly) the... outside circumference is all bread with no cheese or toppings. Came back, issue persists. Cheap on cheese and I have additionalpics to demonstrate it. They may be close, but not worth it. A picture is worth a thousand words. Take a close look. This isblatantly lazy and junk pizza. Read more

If you like cheese and ingredients well dispersed, don't go here. All crust and lacking cheese for more than 1" (2"mostly) the... outside circumference is all bread with no cheese or toppings. Came back, issue persists. Cheap on cheese and I have additionalpics to demonstrate it. They may be close, but not worth it. A picture is worth a thousand words. Take a close look. This isblatantly lazy and junk pizza. Read more