Reviews for Talisman Pizza in Pagosa Springs, CO
Ordered a thin crust Hawaiian pizza and a side salad. The pizza was terrible, we could not even eat it. I don't know if it was... the cheese or the meat. It just tasted off. The crust was hard, burned around the edges. The salad greens were wilted andbrown, but it was actually the best part of the meal. All of this for 29 bucks. The store is dark and dingy. Wish I hadcalled Papa John's or Dominos. I will say that the pizza was prepared promptly. Read more
We paid $70 for 2 medium pizzas and wings. The guy on the phone was super rude. He got to our hotel and I gave him a $10 tip. If... I would?ve looked at the food first I would have never tipped. I didn?t realize how many horrible reviews this guy had on him.Shouldn?t have ordered from there. Would not recommend to anyone that isn?t drunk. Read more
Pizza was burnt probably had to keep it in the oven to melt all that cheese they put on it. For 25$ a pizza you think it would... be good but it was not Gordon Ramsey would probably smack the owner and his mamma for serving that pizza to the public. Ownerwas also very rude and has no respect for anyone but himself. but hey I would be mad at the world too if most people thought mypizza was trash hahaha Read more
This pizza was so good and fresh! We ordered late and the service was great along with the food. We head breadsticks and a salad... too but those were gone too fast! Thanks for a great late night pizza experience! Read more
Best pizza in Pagosa, with delivery until 3am most nights! Sourdough crust is delicious, and fresh toppings are legit. Not a... huge fan of the Italian sausage Bruce uses, but everything else we've had has been fantastic. Bold pepperoni + double mushroom+ basil is our goto, and it's a winner! Read more
Given that it was the only thing open later around here I ordered from them. Service wasn't bad, again, was open late and... delivered, but otherwise was really not very good at all. Simply the recipes used, the dough, sauce etc. I ordered a Hawaiianbecause the white pizza wasn't available, and idk how but the pizza was awful. Read more
Had a great experience at Talisman pizza. Was craving pizza at 10:30 at night and this was the only pizza place open. I was... very satisfied with quality of the pizza, definitely what I call ninja turtle pizza. Will definitely be back next time I?m inPagosa Springs! Read more
Ok... I understand that this is the only pizza place open late. However, i read the reviews and didn't expect much... but, this... place is DELICIOUS!!! We recommend it to everyone!!! We had pep and mushroom. DELICIOUS!!! Read more