Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Sand Lake, FL

Went for dinner 11/4. We’ve been there many times but this is my first review. If you love a coal fired pizza, Anthony’s... does it right! Host said it would be about a 15 minute wait, there is absolutely no waiting area, so your always in the way ofsomeone while waiting for a table. WaIt was only about 7-8 minutes. Service was slow, but it was at capacity. I guess we were soexcited to eat the pizza I didn’t get a picture of it, but it never disappoints! Read more

Order a 12" cheese pizza. Light sauce extra cheese. It was so burnt, you could hit it and it's sound like a brick lol. The staff... were super friendly tho. I took it to go. Had to eat it because kids refused to wait more for a fresh one. Read more

I have eaten there pizza 4-5 times now. To be honest I used to love it. Lately it’s all crust and not much else. This time... we opted to add 4 meat balls. These were not worth. They looked and tasted old. One of them is actually just a half. Twolittle slivers of bread for four 4 meat balls, really. Oh and a dollop of ricotta cheese. 13 bucks is a complete rip off. What do you get if you order only 2. Read more

Coming off the heels of an unpleasant experience at another restaurant, we were pleasantly surprised how welcoming everyone at... Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza was. Since it was our first visit they gave us a sample of their garlic knots and wings. YUM. Thefood was AMAZING Our server Daniel took great care of us. Ask for him when you come in. The ambiance is warm and friendly,you feel like family. That's just want we needed tonight! Yall. Stop by Anthony's Wood Fire Pizza when you get to Orlando.You need them in your life. Read more

Every time someone asks me where my favorite pizza is, I say here. Flavors are very pronounced and fresh, the coal fired oven... gives all of their baked foods an elevated texture and flavor. I tried their wings for the first time today and mixed theBuffalo with the garlic flavor which was a fantastic idea. It came with two pieces of some lovely rosemary foccacia or some typeof delicious Flatbread. The Paulies pie is my go to with the baby meatballs, sausage, sweet peppers and ricotta. Service isalways a hit here as well! They anticipate your needs and genuinely want to provide a good experience. Thank you to Janelletoday :) Read more

Ordered the Pauli pictured here. And also recommend the carnivore which we ate too fast to get a picture of. The service was... awesome. Our server Brittany took care of our big party of 11. And the manager came over to make sure all was well too. Thecrust of the pizza is phenom. Highly recommend Read more

First time eating a coal fire pizza and I must say that it did not disappoint. Delicious! We ordereda side of Garlic Knots, one... 12" Caprese Pizza, one 16" Carnivari Pizza, and one 16" Pepperoni and Extra Cheese pie. The Carnivori pie was really good. Read more

Great night out for pizza and other good eats. Marissa took great care of us from start to finish. The original wings were... excellent and totally different, served dry but with caramelized onions. We ordered one carnivori pizza and one with arugula.These were super-flavorful with the distinct char on the edges of crust. We also had an order of meatballs and an oven roastedchicken sandwich on foccacia bread. Clearly this is a pizza joint but everything on the menu is outstanding. Read more