Reviews for Off The Wall Sandwich Company in Orchard Park, NY

I first saw this place from Tik Tok for having literally "off the wall" type food items. Then I saw Dion Dawkins Advertising... them and knew I had to come check it out, and I was NOT disappointed. We ordered the Bills Mafia Burger which had a thick juicypatty, with maybe three thick cut Pieces of bacon a hefty scoop of chicken wing dip, a chicken finger and blue cheese all onthe burger. It was pure insanity but genius at the same time but it sure was delicious! We also ordered French fries which hadwere lightly battered and fried, and a order of Buffalo Parmesan Chicken fingers that were also very good! Our server was Great!But only saw two employees and they were pretty busy when we were there, so PLEASE be patient and understanding! Definitely gocheck them out! Especially if your a buffalo bills fan! Read more

Burnt chicken fingers with barely any chicken inside of the fingers. Mac and cheese mediocre at best by 3 year old didn't even... want it. I wouldn't bother to try something else. Service wasn't bad but we were the only people when we arrived. Read more

Got my companion and my cook type switched and when I asked for it to be microwaved for a little longer I got looks from... everyone from the server to the kitchen people...at that point I just wanted to leave. Pretzel logs were only thing worth meeating. Read more

So this place def comes off as like little pizza shop but delivers big! Everyone was super friendly. We went in with 6 (picky)... kids and they all found something they like without an issue. The menu choices were insane! And delicious too! I got "The Bird"and having been craving another one all week. If you don't dine here at least once, you're sorely missing out! Wish we had onecloser to home! Read more

Lived up to its name for sure! I have been seeing tons of Facebook sponsored ads with mouth watering food and we found ourselves... in OP today so decided to give it a try. We placed an order online from a park 6 minutes away…drove to the restaurant, ran inmy 7 year old to use the bathroom and the food was already done. We have a family of 5 and ordered 2 appetizers too. Very fastservice. We also drove about 15 minutes home (which is usually when most food becomes soggy, slides in the boxes etc.) and thebuns were still perfectly crisp. My VERY picky 7 year old said it was the best grilled cheese sandwich she had ever had.Everything was delicious. Only suggestion is to warm/thin the marinara sauce a little more, it was playing hard to get and keptcoming out in one blob. I read through some other reviews and wanted to remind you, you can’t please everyone, and the generalpublic has no idea what it’s like to own and operate a business and pour your heart and soul into it to be criticized andpublicly rated for uncontrollable issues. From a fellow small business owner to another, excellent work. Your effort andcreativity does not go unnoticed. Thanks for an awesome dinner! Read more

We had to check out the new sandwich place for lunch. When we entered and went to the counter, they asked if we wanted to eat in... or take out. When we said eat in, it was like a regular sit-down restaurant. They have a small selection of cans of beer and SOmany sandwiches (burgers, melts, deli wraps, appetizers). We had the crab Rangoon rolls (kinda like pizza logs), the Pig ManMelt, and the Trainwreck Melt, with tater tots and onion rings. We enjoyed it. Only star deduction because it's a little pricyfor a lunch place. Read more

Friendly and fast service. Burger and grilled cheese were good. Salad not so much. Wouldn't order that again. Chicken was tough... and bacon seemed like it was from a package (not cooked in kitchen). Not much lettuce either. Other then that, it was good. Read more

We have been dying to try Off The Wall and we were lucky enough to the have the opportunity this past weekend. The menu had a... lot of items. It was mostly a ton of unique sandwich and burger combinations along with some starters, salads, specials and akids menu. The variety of choices made it hard to make a selection but we were finally able to narrow it down. I had the BillzMafia burger, no bun, and I was thrilled they offered sweet potato fries. The burger was tasty and juicy, plenty of blue cheesecrumbles, thick cut bacon and chicken wing dip as toppings. There was also a chicken finger tossed in for good measure. It wasvery rich and filling, it would be a good option to split. I could only eat half and I brought the rest home for dinner. Mysignificant other tried The Ralph. He says it was delicious. The cheese, wing dip, bacon and chicken finger were a greatcombination and they didn’t skimp on toppings. The menu said there was fried chicken in this sandwich. He tells me a chickenfinger is a more accurate description of what he was served. There were gluten free bun and bread options which was a hugeplus. The feeling of the place was casual but nice. Inside the restaurant there was plenty of seating or you could take out aswell. If you choose to dine in they offered table service so no one was standing around, a nice touch. Our server, McKenzie, wasvery friendly and helpful. She quickly found answers to all my questions about ingredients. She was a fantastic server and adefinite asset to the restaurant. We had a nice time and enjoyed our food. We can’t wait to come back and try more menuitems. Read more