Reviews for Jeremiah's Italian Ice in Orange Park, FL
Awesome little shop with friendly employees. It was my first time trying italian ice swirled with vanilla ice cream. Honestly... the vanilla ice cream was one of the best soft serves I?ve ever had, creamy, rich and it brought a lightness to the flavor richitalian ice. The environment was bright and clean. Definitely going back. Read more
I went here with my mother, sister and nephews. Everyone had fruit ice or gelati with fruit ice and vanilla ice cream. Except... my mom. Everyone enjoyed their dessert. Unfortunately for my mom she got cookies and cream ice and vanilla ice cream and itwas pretty disgusting. My advice would be to steer clear of anything that isn't fruit when combining it with ice cream. I hadblack cherry and it was absolutely perfect, the kids had mango and passionfruit with pop rocks sprinkled over it and apparentlya good time was had by most. Prices were reasonable all 5 of us got what we wanted for 28 dollars including tax and gratuity. Read more
We love this place. Awhile back they started having cookie toppings, that really took things to the next level of tastiness.... They're also open later than most establishments that sell ice cream, as such this is the perfect late night treat! Read more
This place is the best dessert store in all of Orange Park! The staff is friendly and the gelatis are really good. They have a... wide variety of flavors to choose from, but I usually order the strawberry gelati with vanilla ice cream. Definitely recommendedif you have a sweet tooth like me! Read more
Love their Italian ice and gelati. So many to choose from. Very nice staff. Helpful and they also give free samples before you... try something new. LOVE THEM. My son is the one who told me about this place. They also give good serving sizes for your money. Read more
This is some crazy good ice cream/ Italian ice. We got 3 flavors with ice cream mixed together, they were all amazing.... Blueberry, peach and cotton candy which was heavenly. Read more
Usually get a blueberry gelati but last time I got horchata. I wasn't a huge fan of that one but this one will always be my go... to. Fast service even if the line is wrapped around the corner & superb customer service Read more
Wow! I didn?t want to go here but my wife talked me into it! Line was a little long but moved quickly! They had a friendly... employee outside that helped us quickly choose something delicious! Thank you all for a great experience and I will definitelybe back! Read more