Reviews for Nancy's Pizza in O'Fallon, MO
Had basically a supreme minus the mushrooms. It was a 45 minutes wait time. ????The wait was SO WORTH IT. I didn't know their... were still pizza places that make their own sauce. The pizza ???? was delicious! The crust perfection. The sauce perfect. Idon't like my pizza or my spaghetti to have a sweet taste. It's Saint Charles/Saint Louis region, so I naturally expect to tastesweet sauce. ????????But this tasted like an authentic Italian style dish. So good even with a slightly higher price tag, thanmost pizza places. If you like real food. This is the place to go. Their cheese bread was also very good. Read more
We have ordered from here 5 times now - greatest pizza in Missouri! We order both the Chicago style and the thin everytime. ... Took us 14 years to find pizza that doesn't taste like a cracker. We decided tonight it's the sauce that is truely amazing andstands out from the bland pizza's we've tried. Read more
Ordered our first pizza from here yesterday. An extra large thin crust, it was awesome and they could not have been any nicer... to deal with. Calling in our order was quick and easy, and pick up was quick and smooth. Both the person on the phone and theone at the counter were super nice and friendly. We are looking forward to our next of many visits. Read more
A few friends have talked about it so decided to try. Wasn?t disappointed. Different style of pizza than what I?m use to but... that?s their niche. Would recommend. Read more
On a whim we tried Nancy's pizza we won't be eating anywhere else. We had a cheese stuffed deep dish pizza it was amazing hot... cheese absolutely the best deep dish I have had since I was a kid. We will be recommending Nancy's to all our family andfriends. Read more
Overall both their Deep Dish and Original Thin pizzas are pretty decent (3 star) if you like something different, and a ton of... sauce, the Deep Dish is the way to go. However, the time it takes to make these average quality pizzas is way to high and theWings are just frozen nuggets tossed in sauce. You can see the baking sheet marks in the photo. They're not bad really, justextrememly frozen dinner quality. The Original Thin had a little more chew-factor than I care for between the crust and thecheese. Overall just the poor service and sides is what brings this location below average. I wouldn't turn down another sliceif offered, but there about 20 other places I'd PAY for another slice. Read more
This was a very good pie with well balanced flavors. I enjoy this style of deep dish once in a while and Nancy's really nailed... it! Better than any other deep dish in the county. I really appreciate the consistency of the pizza, it is the same every time.The garlic cheese bread is good, but nothing special. If you want a good deep dish with a great balance of tomato to cheese andwhatever topping you want, give this ppave a shot! Read more
This is my first time eating this pizza and will be the last. No real taste just a lot of sauce couldn't even find the meat.... Pizza hut and Dominoes have nothing to worry about. Read more