Reviews for Gators Fabulous Frozen Custard in O'Fallon, IL
Our favorite ice cream/custard place. Smoothest custard around, relatively reasonable prices and portions. Try the gator bait!
This visit was a disappointment. I ordered $21 worth of ice cream. The brownie volcanoe had a dollop of ice cream on it and all... the other ice creams (which were supposed to be concretes) being held out the window were already melted. The snickers concretewas supposed to have mixed nuts and I added oreos, only it was oreo dust and peanuts instead. Nothing special about the"specialty concretes". However' The young man at the window taking my order was so courteous Read more
FIRST AND LAST VISIT- I'm embarrased to even have the memory of going to such a retched place. My visit was simply... inconceivable. They were so stingy with the ice cream. And as soon as they handed it out the window we could see every one ofthe ice creams we ordered were already melting. My sister ordered a frappichino specialty concrete, there was nothing specialabout it. They delivered what looked like a Wendy's frosty. It wasnt thick like a concrete and it didn't even taste a bit likecoffee. It was supposed to come with whipped cream and they forgot. My Mom ordered the Snickers concrete and was so disappointedshe gave it away. I ordered the Brownie Volcanoe and I felt like I was eating a dog treat. The brownie was chopped into piecessmaller than bite sized and the guy that took the order made hand signals that the dessert would be big (NEWSFLASH, IT WASNT!).As we were driving away from this disapointment all the other customers (who were ALL white BTW) made these, you shouldn't be in*these parts*, faces. We felt very unwelcomed and like we were rebelling against segregation rules. It was a very white waterfountain and black water fountain situation. All this on Junetenth. The ignorant people who clearly feel like they'd rather havewhite places and black places should be ashamed of themselves. For this to be our first visit you can bet we wont be going againand will be spreading the word to others not to go. Read more
The mud pie custard was good but expensive. It seemed to take a really long time to get the food even though there were at... least four employees working. It would be a good place to take a bunch of kids on a hot afternoon because of the outdoorseating area. Read more
Great hometown, comfy custard. Delicious and cold. Sometimes a bit too sweet but it tastes homemade. They're always nice to our... pup too. Great neighborhood joint. Read more
Frozen custard, say what! Yummy. I kept it simple with a twist cone but the family turned it up with dirt worms... And loved it.... This has been a vacation of ice cream treats. This town may need some other things to do so I don't get fat... But sure istasty. Read more
Bummer, I?ve had way better concretes. Where?s the hot fudge? Where?s the peanut butter? Not the mud slide I?m used to.
Horrible ice cream. I first asked for snickers plus treat, they said they ran out of snickers. So I asked for dipped cone. They... took this order and I paid for it. After a while she came back and asked me if I'm okay with dipped cone in cup because it'smelting. I had to guess that's okay and didn't expect it to be that melting and the workers seems didnt care when i gave a wierdlook at it. It was awful. My ice cream was like a soup. So disappointed. My kids did enjoy their ice cream concrete. Read more