Reviews for Eric's Hand Tossed Pizza & Subs in Oconomowoc, WI

Eric's has always been great except for today the sub I order and garlic bread was way to salty I mean way to salty and the... pizza I order was wrong. I order a half sausage and onion and half sausage I got mushrooms instead.i called about it and theysaid sorry and that was it. I don't think Eric was there. Read more

My wife is a celiac, and when she found out Eric?s had gluten free crust, we decided to give them a try. When we walked in, Eric... was behind the counter himself. Told him it was our first time and he offered a free appetizer right out of the gate. Themozzarella sticks we got were amazing. The pizza we ordered was also fantastic. Great homemade crust, both regular and glutenfree. Definitely will travel back from Lake Mills to enjoy their pizza again. Read more

Great pizza! Awesome crust good toppings(plenty of then) and I've picked up in store and ordered everytime it's hot and... delicious. Wasn't a fan of the mozzarella sticks only cuz they are the wonton wrapped and I just don't like the wrap. Read more

First timer, I had the Italian sub and I was pretty impressed. The ingredients tasted fresh and the sub was a very generous... size. Total price for the sub chips and Gatorade was around $12. That's a tick high in my book but next time I will just get thesub for around $8, which seems in line with competitors and fair for the size. I would also like to try the pizza next time.They also seem a tick high in price but the taste and quality might offset that. I would recommend them and will be back. Read more

The pizza was phenomenal. Definitely worth a visit. Everything was fresh and full of flavor. I even had a nice chat with the... owner while I was waiting for my online order. I would recommend this to my best friend as well as my enemy lol. Leaps andbounds above pizza chains! Read more

Sauce is run of the mill with no clear fresh tomato flavor. Pizza is massive with a simple crust. Crust a bit doughy, but to be... fair we got par-baked which we heated 25 deg hotter and 10 mins longer than recommended. May be crisper in thier oven. Cheese isgood quality, sausage and pepperoni both OK. Overall like most mass quantity pizzas but not worth the $$$$ price tag. Read more

Pizza was made to order, I like the front counter fireplace touch. only negative thing I would have to say is I spoke to 2... people standing there talking about a pick up but they both looked at the 3rd person who was eating and she came out and tookcare of me. Read more

By far, Eric's has the best pizza in Oconomowoc. They use high quality fresh products for their meals. We call ahead by at least... 1 hour as not to have to wait on busy nights. The restaurant is not large, but can seat approximately 20 people. They are tuckedaway in the strip mall between Piggly Wiggly and Robin's on Hwy P in Oconomowoc. I highly recommend trying their pizzas orsandwiches! Read more