Reviews for The New Idle Hour Deli in Oakdale, NY
Best deli by far all around. I'm 280 lbs trust me I know sandwiches.
Staff very friendly & helpful. Variety of meats & salads to choose from. Clean & inviting, would come back.
Yesterday, June 22, 2022 the Idle Hour Deli delivered 30+ Italian and American hero sandwiches to our Sr. Citizen Gate House... Club at the Joyce Fitzpatrick Sr. Center in East Islip. The sandwiches were packed with meat, cheese, lettuce and tomato andenjoyed by everyone, which is an unusual feat among our Seniors????. They were indivually wrapped and delivered at the timerequested. This is not the first time we have used this deli and it will not be the last. We are very satisfied with theirservice. Thank you New Idle Hour Deli. Read more
Before hiking at Connetqoute state Park we stopped here for some lunch. The chicken salad sandwich was excellent with freshly... made chicken salad. The potatoes salad was also homemade. My wife's eggplant panini was also delicious. We also gave into oursweet youth and got a giant brownie which was just unbelievably good. I highly recommend this place. Read more
This is the 3rd time in the last few months I have been given the wrong breakfast sandwich! I either need to start liking... sausage on my sandwich or switch delis. It's so annoying and this time I can't come back and get the correct bacon, egg & cheesebecause I am just too far. =( Read more
Not sure what?s happened to this deli, but while the food may be good, as others have said the quality of service has dropped... tremendously. We frequent this deli a few times a week too, but forgetting simple things and charging an arm and a leg?Unacceptable. Why is syrup being forgotten in the platter? Very simple. If I ask for sausage and lettuce and tomato, why am Igetting bacon and no LT? When we spend almost $30 why is there no OJ in the bag? You have ONE JOB. Do it right or don?t do it atall. This is the regular crew working too. I?m extremely disappointed, and unfortunately you have lost our business. Get youract together and hire the right people. This is also not the first time this has happened. FYI, we spend anywhere from $60-$100a week here. Read more
Great daily hot and cold entrées. Also home-baked coffee cake and brownies. Finally delicious homemade desserts including rice... pudding. Coffee is good too! Read more
Over priced menu, not fresh product including bacon.. Counter help curses and are too old to figure out how the Debit Card... reader works. Read more