Reviews for Mad Martha's Homemade Ice Cream in Oak Bluffs, MA

Not bad. Richardsons ice cream is better on the main land

Fun ice cream shop, good food and friendly staff

Very tasty ice cream and with the trip. Friendly and quickly service.

I have been coming to Marthas Vineyard for as long as I have been alive, and have been going to Mad Marthas as long as I can... remember. There ice cream was always delicious and its somewhere I frequent with family members and friends. Upon discovering Iwas lactose intolerant at the age of 11, I was dissapointed that I would never have Mad Marthas ice cream again. Though, MadMarthas frozen yogurt was something I could definitely settle with. Whenever my friends or family would go to get ice cream, myfather, who is also lactose intolerant, and I would have something to get. This was taken away from us in 2022 when we learnedthat Mad Marthas was no longer serving frozen yogurt, and have switched over to a vegan-friendly Dairy-Free ice cream made ofcoconut and oat milk. I'm not a naysayer, so I tried it of course and was severely dissapointed. Coconut milk also does notsettle in many people's stomachs very well. Now, everytime I come to Mad Martha's, my father and I watch as my friends andfamily enjoy ice cream, while your alternatives are utter garbage. Restock Frozen yogurt and maybe you would see the return ofsome valued customers. Even just simple vanilla. Or god damn sorbet. Read more

Says opened placed order online, paid online, order accepted online drove 10 minutes closed. Now ihave angry wife back at hotel... waiting for her ice cream. Read more

This was not my favorite ice cream. They didn't allow us to try any flavors. We settled on something we didn't love. I really... wish we could have tried a couple of the flavors before committing. The M&M ice cream was not good. The mint and coffee wereokay. They have a sign saying masks are required, but the girl working outside was not wearing a mask covering her nose. Read more

Good ice cream! Large cones and free tasting!

When in the island there's nothing more refreshing than a couple scoops of MAD MARTHA'S at the end of your walking and shopping... in Oak Bluffs. Yummy to my tummy! I enjoyed a scoop of Reeses cup and maple walnut Read more