Reviews for AMORE PIZZA by jack calandra - Pizza Delivery Shop Nutley NJ in Nutley, NJ

Ordered a ?skinny? pie for the first and last time. It was literally BLACKENED crust, so I called to complain. I was told that... this is ?well-done? and their most popular pie and that they sell hundreds of these pies everyday. They?re literally selling youcancer. Won?t be purchasing from this place again. If you like burnt pizza, go for it! Read more

I usually order from the same place but I been hearing good things about this place, so I wanted to try it. I ordered through... slice, slightly more expensive, probably because of the app BUT we all LOVED the pizza. We got one regular pie and I did get aSicilian with pepperoni. I appreciate the cutting to smaller pieces because it?s just such big slices. We are all about thesauce in this family and it was by far the best one I have tasted since moving to Nutley. I ordered a cold sub (Italian sub) awhole. It was beautiful. I like my oil and vinegar on the side and they fulfilled all my requests. The pasta dish was good(stuffed shells) but it?s the pizza and sub that hooked me. The driver was such a friendly gentleman. I look forward to seeinghim more often since I may be ordering from here a little more... Read more

AWESOME THIN PIZZA. AMAZING TASTE AND P3RFECT CRUNCH. BRAVO ????

Overall have tried a lot of different things, consensus, this place has amazing food! Hard rolls seems to big a big ?complaint?... but there?s a difference between hard rolls and stale rolls. I love that the bread stands up to calandras quality, nothingcompares. Quality here is very good in my opinion, food always comes promptly, def a five star pizza place for the area. Read more

Very good experience, fresh sandwiches Chicken parm &? Italian sub is one of the best we?ve tried. Well worth the... money! Delivery was fast and driver was so nice! I recommend 10/10 Read more

Great pizza and great friendly owner (jack). The Sicilian was my favorite with a really good garlicky sauce and the cheese on... the bottom. This is going to be my go to spot in the area! Their 2 slices and a soda for $5 deal cannot be beat. Read more

Wow! I?ve been trying for over 2 years to find a decent pizza place in Nutley and finally this place opened! I only tried the... grandma pie and I was blown away by the crispy crust, fluffy center and tasty sauce. 10/10 this is my new local spot! Read more

Had the regular cheese and the grandma pies. Great authentic quality. Ingredients taste fresh and they have a great balance of... dough, cheese and sauce. Read more