Reviews for Teresa's Pizza-Sagamore Hills in Northfield, OH
First time trying Teresa's, won't be the last. Picked up a Large with sausage and pepperoni. I must admit, when I opened the box... I was underwhelmed - the toppings were under the cheese and the pizza didn't look very "large." But it was delicious, and theydefinitely didn't skimp on anything - plenty of toppings and sauce, and cheese that most places would charge extra for. Goodtexture and flavor to the crust. I almost took off one star because the price seemed high, but the price is actually in linewith what other one-off shops and local chains charge. You can pay much less if you get a promo from a national chain, but butthat level of quality just isn't the same. I can't justify spending this much all the time but Teresa's will be a nice treat nowand then when I want "good" pizza and not just something quick and cheap. Absolutely worth a try. Read more
They always serve exceptional food and service. They have been there a long time an surely beat out Antonio's who rip you off on... delivery an their staff are rude and disgusting. If you want quality, service and a staff plus the owner who truly service theircustomers STICK with Teresa's in Sagamore Square for the best. Read more
Our office orders from this location typically once a week. We love the pizza and the salad. Our order has never been wrong.
Im glad I decided to try this place....I gotta a large pep.and sausage..and it was perfect...taste like the pizza we used to... get...taste like a classic pizza...thank you Teresa's Read more
Pretty terrible pizza. Their sauce is weirdly thin and soupy and tastes like low-quality prepackaged sauce (think Lunchables).... The pizza was light on toppings, drenched in grease, and the crust had a chewy, unpleasant texture. It is the quality I mightexpect from a *very* cheap frozen supermarket pizza. Get a Red Baron frozen pizza instead - you will save a lot of money andget better quality. Read more
Can?t believe some of these negative reviews? I?ve actually never been inside the establishment, I get delivery. Best pizza in... town! Only pizza place on Earth that I don?t have to waste a topping on Extra Cheese because they provide so much. Great job,Teresa?s!!! Read more
Good pizza at a decent price. We were out on a jaunt far from our home in Parma, when my wife exclaims "it's teresa's pizza!"... And tells me we must go get some, its so good, I haven't had it since I was a kid! We pull in and though we've had dinner andits late we order. Soon I find the time has come and I make my way into the homey looking store. The pizza is ready and thesmells are amazing bringing back my childhood memories... I pay the man and return to the car. We dig in before our order iscold. Wise choice. Good food, good times, good life. I recommend Teresa's Pizza. Read more
Love their large pepperoni pizza, eat it fresh and hot or as leftovers either way it doesn?t disappoint!