Reviews for North Tonawanda-Pizza Amore “The Wood Fire Way” in North Tonawanda, NY

Customer service was 5 stars along with how fast I got my pizza. But the pizza itself was unfortunately just a major let down. I... ordered a Medium Cheese and Pepperoni pizza to go. The pizza looked perfect nice and cheesy enough Pepperoni on each individualpiece that I wasn't trying to pick off some from another slice to add to mine and the perfect amount of sauce so that it wasn'tdry tasting but it also wasn't dripping all over you. But there was no flavor to it except for the cheese and Pepperoni. Read more

Very disorganized. Ordered 2 pizzas and when I arrived to pick them up I was told my order wasn't ready even though I arrived... ten minutes past the given pick up time. So I waited another 30 minutes in the parking lot only to be given the wrong order andwhen I said that I didn't order wings now mind you when I arrived I started my name and what I had ordered. When the server wentto check the warmer there were my two pizzas the same two that had been in the warmer when I got there. So I get them home andthey were terrible and cold and vary unenjoyable. This is the second bad experience I've had here so I won't be a customer atthis location any longer. Read more

The chicken fingers were amazing, brick oven, fire burned pizzas are out of this world! My fiancé is obsessed with the... gabagool! He has one at least 3-4 times a week! Honestly refuse to go anywhere else! Also the staff is beyond amazing, veryfriendly, and always going above and beyond! Read more

Phenomenal OMG thank you lord good pizza! Wow! Really delicious. Outstanding wings. I'd had their pizza from their food truck.... Loved it. This is like top 5 pizza in a region that is known for incredible pizza/food. The whole brick oven technique isamazing. Then to see the menu. They have desserts and salads. Service was fantastic. Big easy to park parking lot. Very clean.Great location on Payne near North Tonawanda High School. This pizzeria is a destination! Read more

Ate there 5/16/22. Ordered cheese and pepperoni personal pan and the suggested garlic knots by the cashier. Very thin crust,... spicy pepperoni, burnt crust. Garlic knots, I've had better frozen ones. Taste was very average, not worth the price for bothpizza and knots. No better than little Caesars that was there for years. Read more

Had two pizzas today and they tasted amazing!! Only issue is that I have a weak stomach and am experiencing the consequences... after eating the Smores pizza???? But its well worth it!! I met the owners before they officially opened the NT location atPanes restaurant when at the time I was their waitress! Sweet people and I am so glad that I finally had the chance to indulgein such good pizza! Thanks again guys and I will be back for sure! Read more

So I recently started a job across the street and I didn?t feel like making dinner tonight just so happened I checked the... reviews on Google and they weren?t great but I was feeling lazy wanted to try something new and didn?t want to cook boy am Iglad I got pizza from Pizza amore Literally The best stinger pizza I?ve ever had in my life no joke I got pepperoni pizza forthe kids it was also really good no complaints we will be ordering from here again for sure!!! The staff was amazing!!! Read more

This was my second visit. My first visit i waited 20 minutes longer than my order was to have taken then they forgot to put the... pepperoni on the pepperoni pizza and it wasn't completely cooked. This time I stopped in for a slice. It was so greasy it took 2paper towels to soak up the grease. The slice was burned around the crust and on the bottom in different places. Maybe that'show fire baked pizza is supposed to be but either way not for me and I won't be back. The one thing redeeming is the personworking there was very nice. Honestly I go to a lot of different pizza places and the pizza here I would give no stars ifpossible. Read more