Reviews for Mystic Pizza II in North Stonington, CT

It was a busy Saturday night and the hostess Lauren sat me and was very nice. I can't remember the name of my waitress but she... was nice too. The burger was good and so was the dessert. I also got a pizza to go, I believe it was called the Texas pizza orsomething along those lines. It was an awesome pizza. 10/10 experience, I can't wait to come back. Read more

Ordered a large pie . Thick cheese and robust sauce. Old school pizza the way it should be . Spacious dining area also has bar... and adjacent dining room. You can also purchase a T-shirt . ?A little slice of heaven ? indeed. Was expecting to see JuliaRoberts but I think she got into acting ???? Read more

Waitress had a nice personality , Next time I'll have to ask to get pizza a medium golden brown . Tuna grinder was very good... ???? The grounds and parking lot was clean and cheerful . Read more

Had a nice dinner here. Split the Mystic calzone which was huge and absolutely stuffed with meat, cheese, and ricotta. Sauce is... delicious. We shared a plate of buffalo chicken wings. Husband said its the best wings he's had in Connecticut. Cocktails weregood too! Very beautiful restaurant, large comfortable booths, and quick service. ???? Read more

This place has amazing food ! Their pizza is the best in town. They use high quality ingredients. Tonight we ordered their... sampler appetizers, a bacon cheese burger and their house pizza. Everything was delicious. Very generous portion sizes. Waitstaff was very pleasant. The place was spacious and well kept. Very clean. I would recommend this place over the original Mysticpizza. Read more

Stopped here on my way home from Rhode Island and I was very happy with my pizza. It tasted fantastic. I will be making this a... regular stop once beach season starts. Read more

My first time here and I was not disappointed! The outside was beautifully kept and the inside was super clean. The booth was... large and quite comfortable. It was staffed well. Our waitress was attentive. No delays at all. Had the best BBQ chicken pizzaever! The dough was perfect. Sauce was amazing, chicken was all over the pizza, not just plopped on, the cheese was unreal!Tasted so fresh. The sweet potato fries were baked to perfection. Not soggy. Not salty. Perfect. Read more

Pizza is always fabulous, I had the Moussaka and it did not disappoint! The salads are huge and their homemade Greek Dressing is... absolutely delicious, the entire menu is good. Service is always top notch too! Read more