Reviews for Sheelen's Fish Market, N. Plainfield, NJ in North Plainfield, NJ

We when on Saturday, September 10, 2022. This was the first time we went here. I travel to different place to write a review on... new place that I eat at. This was handled as the worst place I have eaten at in a long time. Especially for seafood. How can youmass up fried shrimp and shrimp tacos? But I guess you can. ???? very disappointed we spend 45 dollars on tasteless seafood. Thefood came out in less than 2 mins. Cavichi was even worse and tasted like tomato juice. No lime favor at all and no salt orpepper. And they give you only 3 chips with a large bowl of cavichi. Very unbelievable. I spend that much money on food wedidn't even eat. And the selection of drinks was limited and they didn't even have a selection of fresh seafood and they're afish market. Go figure that out ???? lost a custom hands down. Customer service was great. But food takeaways from the customerservice just because it was horrible. Read more

So sorry to report this first time here and just t spent 20.00 on garbage hush puppies taste like sweet doughnuts everything is... not cooked just soft not crispy I even asked to make it crispy my mistake is I paid b4 getting my nasty meal tried to givethem business and when I tried to go back they were closed I support new business but u guys stole my 20 bucks Read more

Delicious lobster roll with thick cut fries and a drizzle of Old Bay Seasoning (by request) Very fresh cole slaw and looking... forward to my next visit for lunch. Side note, I took the food to go and it was wrapped to keep the fries hot and crispy. Read more

Very disappointed, paid $30 for a lobster roll, got a broken stale bun and soggy flavorless fries.

Probably the worst seafood dinner I have ever had. Ordered a few different things to try them all. The fried shrimp platter was... disgusting. All batter and awful fries. The fried crab was all filler, cold and disgusting. The fries were just as bad. Thelobster bisque was the worst I haven?t ever tasted. I lover lobster bisque, I threw this away. Read more

We stopped by the location on Rt 22 for lunch. Started off with a clam strip appetizer, followed by the seafood egg roll. Both... items were fresh, tasteful and perfection. Basket of clam strips was extremely bare for amount they give. Then we ordered thebattered codfish sandwiches. Servings were large, fresh and extremely good. Location is a must try if you pass by..... Read more

Great service. The poke bowl was really dry and the rice was hard, not sure because of the time of night we went. The fish and... chips was really good. Hopefully the poke bowl is better next time, will eat here again. Read more

The food is delicious! Very good customer service as well. We got a flounder sandwich and fish tacos. Both had really good... flavor and tasted fresh. We?ve lived in Rhode Island and this food was right up there with New England seafood. Prices were alsogreat. We?ll definitely be back! Read more