Reviews for Bayshore Cafe & Pizza in North Fort Myers, FL

It's amazing. The stuffed shells are to die for

Fatta-A Mano- After all the hoopla I decided to check it out. Sorry to say I was somewhat disappointed. I was expecting home... made authentic Italian food, but got pre-made pizza dough and bread sticks exactly like the ones at Olive Garden. If they takeshort cuts like this I?m really not interested in seeing any more. If you open a restaurant?.don?t take short cuts, it neverends well. Best of luck! Read more

This place is amazing. I can't say enough good things about them. Food is always on point and made exactly as you ask for it.... Waitress is phenomenal its always the same one! Fast service, good prices, amazing service. HIGHLY Recommended! Read more

Went in with a friend to place a to go order, stood at the counter, was first ignored then told by the lady with the bob that... she had three tables and a to go order. She seemed annoyed that we were there and was all around rude. I?ve ate here plenty oftimes and have never been treated like such dirt. The younger waitress with the glasses is cool, but I won?t be coming back tothis place. Thanks bob lady Read more

For my first visit I had simply a bacon and egg toasted Rye breakfast sandwich with no cheese and I got to tell you, it was... delicious! The waitress that helped me was appetit lady with red highlights in her hair and she had the most wonderful andfriendly disposition. The atmosphere is very relaxed and has pictures of on Cinema actors on the walls and a terracotta ceilingleading to the hallway to the bathroom so, it's kind of a different and weird look but the breakfast sandwich was delicious andI look forward to coming back this weekend to try the pizza that I hear it's so delicious! Read more

My husband and I had been wanting to try out this restaurant because it has such good reviews and we were finally able to catch... a time when it wasn't so busy so we had lunch there. I have to say it is really good, our waitress was very pleasant, friendlyand even entertaining with her sense of humor. My husband had the cheeseburger plate and I just had a BLT but everything was sogood. I had some of his fries and they were so tasty. I asked the waitress what made them so good and different from your run ofthe mill fries and her answer was, " it's an ancient Chinese secret", so she wasn't telling but they sure are good. My BLT waswonderful and my husband really enjoyed his cheeseburger. We want to go back and have breakfast because they have a great menuand like the waitress told us, they have everything but waffles on there and that is true. We had a great experience and can"twait to go back! Read more

Been here 2 times with my 9 year old and we both enjoyed it. Food is great and staff is courteous. Would recommend to anyone... looking for a nice homecooked meal. Read more

Nice decor. Good food! Great prices. Service is fast and efficient. A wonderful neighborhood place.