Reviews for New York Pizza & Pasta in Norman, OK
My go to NY style pizza joint shut down on Main St so I decided to give this place a try. I was so happy I did!!! I ordered an... 18 inch pepperoni and it was delicious!! Plenty of cheese and pepperoni along with enough sauce. The taste was spot on andcooked perfectly. One 18 inch pizza should easily feed 3-4 people. I was full after 2 slices!! I've found my new go to pizzajoint!! Read more
I guess I am not destined to find decent pizza in Oklahoma. I gave this place a last ditch try and I will never know how their... food is. My order took over 45 minutes to be delivered and went through FOUR drivers!! Obviously when it arrived, my overpricedpizza was stone cold. So I called the store and someone picked up and hung up. Nice. Called back and asked why that happened.Man refused to acknowledge that it did. Good move. He really made me feel like a valued customer. Then we talked about myorder. He blamed the delivery service (which restaurants love to do now) and just kept babbling. He was a real d**k wad tome. Now here is my challenge to him and other restaurant owners who want to play this game of splitting the customer betweenthem and the deliver companies: Whatever happens on the delivery end affects your product and your reputation. You should beinvested in that. You should be on the phone with Uber requesting an explanation for why your hard work and creation was wastedby languishing for a delivery driver. Your relationship is with them. I have no stake in it. If you want to make your businesslook good and impress your customers, handle these problems and don't play the blame game. Customers just want product andservice and don't care about your issues with delivery. By all means, do not disgrace your customer because you cannot getthings to work smoothly. I hope he enjoys that cold pizza I returned. It should be in an undisclosed location as we speak. Read more
True New York style pizza here. While doing college orientation with my daughter we had lunch here. They do have different hours... posted for summer time so be mindful of this. My daughter got the meatball sub and pasta salad it came with, while my husbandand I got pizza slice. It was agreed this reminded us of the pizza in New York. Food was really good, will be back whenvisiting get during the school year. Also noticed they have karaoke on Friday nights. Read more
We are from out of town and went out of our way to come back because we really liked it the first time we tired it. However,... this time around we had a horrible experience. The customer service was terrible. We were not acknowledged when we walked up tothe counter, and another employee had to tell a woman to take our order. Once she did, she was not nice at all and acted like wewere an inconvenience to her. We ordered an 18" pizza that was half bianca and half pepperoni and sausage, and the total cameout to $34.00. This pizza is good, but definitely not worth that much. She rang us up in the most expensive way possible. Wewill not be back. Read more
Awesome pizza even the hotdogs was delich..casher not so friendly ???? I will come again
This was the first time I've ever been here or even heard of it. I've always wanted to try some real NY style pizza and man this... is truly the best pizza in Oklahoma. The owner is from the Bronx and the style of the shop looks like something from New York.The pizza is really to die for and made fresh n hot. They also have some New York soda and a bar inside also. Location isperfect for business and just a nice vibe all around, I will for sure be back. Read more
Not the best first experience!! The Alfredo noodles was way over cooked and DRY! They gave us the pizza smooshed together, the... Stromboli had very few pieces of meat and 90% mozzarella! It was the best tasting thing I mean can?t go wrong with cheese andpepperoni and ham! The pasta was nasty, the chicken tasted good! Prob won?t return 43$ Wasted! Online states they close at 930pmso with it being 9pm I?m sure they was just ready to get home! Read more
The food here is very delicious, everything I have ever ordered has been excellent. I always resort back to the chicken... parmesan...it is the best I've ever eaten. The atmosphere is always excellent and the staff are very friendly. You will alwaysrun into the owner Danny he comes around to make sure you are happy with the service. This is a weekly eating place for me andthe wife.....I highly recommend this restaurant. Read more