Reviews for Papa Al's Pizza in Newtown, CT
Ordered meatball parm, no bread, mushrooms and pepperoni, $15 later, so disgusting won't eat it. 3 meatballs, 3 pepperoni and a... handful of mushrooms. Do better Read more
Sicilian was very good. Buffalo Chix Slice Was literally half the size of a regular slice. Overall tasty
I LOVE IT HERE! The staff is so enthusiastic and the food is delicious. The pizza made by the kindest man Rino is the best I... ever had which is saying a lot because im from the pizza capital New York. If you want some authentic Italian food check thisspot out!! Read more
Decent Connecticut style pizza with good tasting sauce and solid toppings. This is one of my wife's favorite spots but it... doesn't stand out for me. The pricing is standard and they do have a lot of offerings. Read more
One of the better pizzerias in the area, this is the place I go to most. Would be even better if they got the crust on the... underside of the pizza a little crispier, that's just my preference though. I guess I could ask for a "well done" pie. Read more
The pizza is just tough...no real sauce so your not getting a nice saucy bite. Dry pizza with a tough crust is just not for me.... Tried on 3 different occasions and not one time was it great. I think they cater to too many options on their menu so it theyaren't being particularly great in one area. The chicken tenders are delicious but the wings are not good. They were over cookedand not enough bbq on them. The pasta dish was good (chicken Alfredo) and the bake bread was nice and moist. Whatever they dofor the dinner roll they need to do for the pizza crust. The garlic bread was also good. Will come back for a few items butdefinitely never the pizza. Read more
I followed one of the other reviewers advice and had the the chicken Marsala pie, ????! So much flavor in each bite! They also... carry all sorts of pizzas and other delicious entrees. Btw, don?t leave without a slice of cannoli pie ?????? Read more
BEST pizza place in Newtown hands down better then Franco's!! They all know me and remember me. The pizza is a little bit... greasier than I would prefer, but I don't care because they are my favorite pizza place in the whole entire world. The fact thatthey are a minute and a half from my house also does not hurt but I love them, the owner is amazing! The girls that work thereare also amazing! The atmosphere is friendly and like eating at home. I recommend them to anyone that will listen to me. IRL. ILOVE YOU GUYS! YOU'RE THE BEST! Read more