Reviews for Square Boy Pizza in Newmarket, ON
I got a loaded large square pizza. Opened up the box and the pizza looked fantastic. Digging into a corner slice, toppings... looked to be in good proportion. The first bite, it was delicious!!! The cheese, toppings, sauce, you tasted it all. Thecrust was more thin which provided a little extra crunch to the bite.. If you're in Newmarket and looking for a pizza pie, lookfor these guys. It not the cheapest but it's well worth the extra few bucks for quality. Read more
The pizza at square boy is pretty good, I ordered two large Pizzas with the garlic butter brushed on the crust and it was pretty... tasty. The pizza itself is definitely on the floppier side but the crust thin and crispy. The biggest reason for the five starshowever, was the gentleman that served me, didn't catch his name, but great service from him. Read more
Pizza tasted great, but they forgot to add the garlic butter crust topping that I was so excited to try ????
First time ordering. Ordered on line and picked up. I didn?t have to create an account. Pizza was hot and ready on time.
I very much enjoyed this pizza. For me it was light on the tomato sauce but that allowed me to taste more of the toppings. The... pizza was light and the dough is delicious and I actually enjoyed eating the crust (which I usually leave behind). There alsowasn't as much sodium as there is in other pizzas. We got a few chicken tenders which were good too. We ordered online and thetiming was good and they had excellent service. Read more
Unfortunately I have to give this a 1 star. Apart from it taking 2 hours for delivery. The 3 pizza?s arrived cold, hard and... missing toppings. The pizzas were all suppose to be well done and they were far from that. I did call and spoke to a manager whohad no authority to do anything and said I would need to speak to the owner. the young man was pleasant with me but had zeroability to help. I placed my complaint with him for the owner. I ordered through the website and it is not clear that it isdelivered by DoorDash (I would have never ordered if I had known). So the one star is based on correctness, quality,presentation, taste, customer satisfaction and value. It is a 1 Star across the board. This pizza place is comparable to a pizzapizza or less. I personally do not recommend unfortunately. I will update this review once the owner contacts me. Read more
Love the pizza here. Slices are great, but the walk-in special (Large 3 topping) is fantastic. Staff are friendly, and helpful... too. Order your pizza and pick it up after checking out the rest of the store. Read more
I love this pizza! It is my favorite so far. Prices are great and affordable for this crazy economy!