Reviews for Isabella's in Newcastle, WY
Completely UNEXPECTED! My burger was served HOT and perfectly medium and JUICY! The green beans with bacon were also served HOT?... not tepid, not lukewarm on top only? hot. The salmon and rice platter was piping hot and delicious- not dry at all. I wasprepared for a typical small town cafe experience- what I got was anything but that. All of it was DELICIOUS, coupled with thefriendly efficient staff?I was blown away. My mom has talked about that salmon platter for three straight days now. Keep it up! Read more
I took steak and salad, salad was dead in day prior and a steak was cooked in an oil from garbage. When I asked Isabella ?do she... care about customer opinion she just laughs. Place only for locals, with them she doing her best. If you are tourist - runaway. Read more
We wanted some places new so we drove over to New Castle and went to Isabella's. It was well worth the drive and money. The food... was so good!! We will be back!! The service was great!! Read more
Will eat here again!!! Driving through and wanted some place to eat, we lucked out and found Isabella's. Unique twist on typical... American food. Very good Read more
Great local place with a very diversified menu. Host was friendly. All the items we ordered we?re delicious.
We went here for early dinner on the hotel recommendation. We had the cranberry chicken salad (it was big) and cup of tomato... totillini soup. One word describes it... WOW! Ok here's another word or 2... Awesomely delicious!! The homemade bread that camewith the salad, well let's just say, in could have ate a whole loaf!!! You HAVE to go here!!!!!!! So worth the price! Ourwaitress Autumn was so very pleasant. Read more
Nice, casual atmosphere. We ordered the spinach artichoke dip (in house/homemade), fried ravioli, portabella mushroom... tortellini, and brisket flatbread. We left with our tastebuds and tummies satisfied! They have an outdoor dining area that isdog friendly. Highly recommend! Read more
The quality of food did not match the high prices of this place, my waitress was more concerned about hanging out in the bar... then helping us. I love pizza but this place hands down had the worst pizza sauce I've ever tasted in my life I thought it wasbarbecue sauce at first. I had to ask the waitress what kind of sauce you put on my pizza that's how bad it was. Read more