Reviews for Jersey Mike's in Newcastle, WA

The staff is really friendly and tries to make small talk with you which is nice.. if you're in the mood for small talk. The... food is great, there's really nothing much to complain to be honest. Read more

Awesome work force. The workers are super friendly and helpful. The restaurant is constantly clean and orderly. The sandwiches... are awesome. Read more

Really enjoy getting a sandwich from this restaurant. They make a wicked sandwich. Fresh meats and veggies. Staff really makes... you feel like family. Prices a tad higher than other sandwich shops but well worth it. Read more

Today I received amazing customer service from both Andy and Jeremiah at the Newcastle location. We were unable to pick up our... online order earlier in the day and after a quick and pleasant call, the ASM was able to ensure we still received our order,freshly made. We always receive great quality from this Jersey Mike?s, the employees are always inviting, the restaurant isclean, and the orders are efficient. Thanks again guys! Read more

Busy shop but the staff were doing a great job keeping on top of it. Delicious subs with very generous portions.

It's my first time at Jersey Mike's, they offered me a free cookie. The sandwiches are a bit small for the price but I haven't... been to fast food in a couple years so my guess is that's just how things are now. Read more

The sandwiches are good and the quality is pretty consistent. They're a whole lot better than Subway that's across the street.... That being said, the prices are very high for what you get and the service is sub average (no pun intended). The service is okat best. For some reason they always prioritize online orders over in-store customers. When I went in there, I was the onlycustomer in the store. They didn't start making my order until they were done making about 5 sandwiches for online orders. Thepeople that ordered online weren't even there to pick them up, why not prioritize the in-store customer? Also, it doesn't looklike there is any leadership among the employees. It looks like a few disorganized teenagers doing whatever withoutsupervision. In summary, it's fine if you're craving a particular type of sandwich or if you have a coupon. Otherwise, there arebetter options in the area. Read more

At last! So happy Jersey Mike's is here. Need a quick but satisfying lunch, snack or easy supper? This is the place for sure.... What I like is the #13 with the different meats and the smooth provolone cheese. Get it Mike Style, which is lettuce, tomato,etc. and it's extra fresh tasting and good. You can also ask for the sub to be made into a wrap, or try it as a salad if you'reavoiding bread. This location is super convenient. It's in the same row of shops as QFC. Plenty of parking. Fast service. Bestidea yet: grab sandwiches to go and take them to the park or sit at home with a movie and your Jersey Mike's sub. It's a greatchange of pace from pizza. Love this place! Read more