Reviews for Eddie's Gourmet Pizza in Newburgh, NY
AMAZING and DELICIOUS!!! We are from Savannah, GA and was celebrating my son's graduation and ordered lg pepperoni pizza for... delivery 45min b4 closing ????. After ordering, we get a call from here right away to inform us they were out of bread ????(ordered a sandwich as well) So we did a stromboli instead. They were so nice over the phone and fast delivery!! Read more
Eddie?s catered an event for a funeral this week. The chicken in the chicken Parmesan entree and sandwich was tender and... flavorful. The stuffed shells were excellent too! Everyone loved all the food. We will most certainly be ordering from themagain. Thanks for making a hard day that much easier and enjoyable. Read more
Awesome simple pizza, requested it to be well done and they cooked it perfect!???? delivery was prompt and smooth. Chicken sub... is simple and delicious crispy chicken and condiments not overwhelming. Highly recommended Read more
I have had their pizza very good, their wraps are also good. I just recently ordered chicken parmesan dinner with penne pasta... and sauce. The pasta was good and salad with warm fresh Italian bread. I did not like the Chicken Parmesan. It seemed like itwas the kind you buy frozen. It did not taste like a fresh boneless chicken breast neither the bread crumbs that covered it. Read more
Eddie's Gourmet Pizza came through in a pinch! I ordered food last min the day before my daughter birthday. He was so pleasant... and helpful on the phone! I got 4 pies, tray of penne, meatballs and sausage & peppers. He even got rolls for me and they wereso soft! All so delicious! And the meatballs are to die for! I also was to pick the order up the next day and was not able to. I called them 2 hours before the party to ask if they could deliver it and there was no hesitation they said yes. The deliveryguy was so nice and sweet. He helped bring everything in and even asked if I needed anything else! Eddie's will be my go to forevery party! Read more
Everyone in the area knows this place. Unfortunately it is these older patrons who keep this place running. That said, even... some, like my in laws won't go anymore. Their food is nothing short of disgusting. We tried again today and my wife's wrap wasfull of chicken fat and it had to be thrown out. My chicken was ice cold, had no flavor, was not cooked, looked like it came outof a can and was dripping with white water instead of ranch. Beyond gross. There was only 2 kids working there that looked to beabout 16. What a joke! DO NOT EVER GO! Read more
Great pizza... Friendly staff. Theres not a single person who enjoys Italian food that has not heard of Eddie's gourmet pizza... ... Not in this area! Read more
Very disappointed with the way mistakes are handled. They never take fault when they screw up an order. It seems to be the... people working at night that I have an issue with. Menu says one thing but she argues no it doesn't. I've spent my last dimeat this establishment. They have now lost my take out and any future catering orders. I'll be sure to pass my experience on toothers Read more