Menu for Tomelly's Pizza in Newburgh, IN

Tomelly?s is a new gem in Newburgh that will quickly become a staple in the community. We went with a big group of people so we... got to try a wide range of pizzas and sandwiches. Everything was excellent! But, the ham sandwich is really what stood out tome. The employees are all super warm and friendly. This is a unique and fun atmosphere - I strongly recommend! Read more

Pizza is really good, and they give you a ton of cheese on it! Which I like it that way. The cheese bread is really good too.... They dont have alot of drink selection, no sweet tea or many diet drinks, but I guess that could change. They are also notcheap, a little expensive to eat there. Read more

Great pizza. Waited 40 minutes for ONE pizza on a Sunday night with about 12 people inside. Safe to say I will never be dining... in here again. Read more

Wonderful!!!! We just had the meats pizza and cheese bread and this is now by far our favorite pizza place!! Everyone there was... super nice and toppings are hot and fresh! We will be back ... Plus I have already spread the word to family!! Read more

Didn't know this place existed until it was suggested to me on Maps! I had wanted to try Fat Boys, but they unfortunately close... at 7 on Sundays, so we decided to give another local business a shot. Service was great and all staff were exceptionallyfriendly, and the location is very clean and has a surprising spare and sleek modern aesthetic. The menu options are fairlysmall and basic at the current time, and the pizza is una style, although not quite what I would describe as "cracker crust". We tried The Farm, which is a twist on a chicken, bacon, and ranch pizza with a white sauce and onions and peppers. The saucewas very flavorful and the amount of cheese was very generous. My only critique is that the pizza could've been cooked longer,as I like it to be decently browned and crispy with the onions/vegetables very soft - but, this is very much a personalpreference. The cheesy bread is SUPER cheesy and has a great garlic flavor and surprisingly fluffy crust. Overall, I reallyenjoyed my experience and would definitely patronize them again! I feel like they are still ironing out some kinks as they area very new business, but they have some very compelling flavors, ambience, and service. Read more