Reviews for Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria in Newark, NY
When food arrived my salad had all the toppings I removed online while ordering and also my calzone was not right. I paid extra... for broccoli and it had none. And barely any chicken in it. Read more
Not consistent. Either over cooked. Not cooked at all. When you call to inquire about your messed up order they hang up on you.... All frozen ingredients but still can?t produce consistency.. 10/10 DO NOT recommend. Highly recommended supporting a local smallpizzeria instead. Read more
Lots of places to buy pizza in this town. It tasted OK but not worth the high prices they charge.
Whenever we are wanting a good pizza, we just go to Salvatore's!! We've tried a lot of pizzas too!!
Terrible! My roommate ordered chicken wings. No blue cheese!! He ordered 2 extra blue cheese dressings. Charged him for them. I... had 2 bites of my grilled chicken sandwich. I threw it out. It was overdone.. It was tough and rubbery. It tasted like thechicken was perhaps going bad. $38.72 never again. Read more
It's the calzones!!! There are several pizzerias within a few blocks of this Salvatore's location, but this is the place to get... the BEST pizza in the area. I love their pizza and at least one of the employees at this location recognizes me and even lets meknow when I have earned enough points for FREE PIZZA! You can't beat that! Their dining room is spacious for a pizza place and Ihave brought many friends here to enjoy a sheet at a booth. Read more
Super happy with this location! As with all Salvatores, it was super clean top to bottom including the rest room. I always... wanted to try their steak sub and I'm glad it did. It was superb! They must use a good quality beef and the roll was amazing. Iwouldnt hesitate to try it again. Read more
Place has gone down hill. Order pizza and show up and 3 to 4 employees are standing around talking and you order was never... made. No apology from no one. Email the contact place to give them a heads up and they just make excuses. Take your moneyand go to another pizza place. Read more