Reviews for Pontillo's in Newark, NY
Ordered a small pizza and cheese curds... small pizza... yeah more like a personal pan pizza... slices were bite size. So small... and price was 15.. had 3 ppl to feed who don't eat much but no way did that "small" feed 3... had to order a medium which cost25.. just for extra cheese n pepperoni... medium was more like a small... guess I should have went with large. Pricy food n notgood quantity :/ Read more
I dont normally leave reviews but Last night, my boyfriend and I ordered pizza, garlic bread and mozz sticks, and the food... tasted alright. It was a little expensive but didn't mind. However, an hour later we started feeling very nauseous, and thatstarted the Neverending series of running to the bathroom. If it was just me, I would think it didn't agree with me. However,since it was both of us, it just sucked and we definitely think we got food poisoning from here. Read more
Excellent location! This is one of the few Pontillos left that really actually does have the original flavor which, if you... remember what that is like, its really darn good. The service at this location is also impeccable. I have gotten slices andwhole pies and they all taste the same and they are all fantastic. Try it if you haven't. You will not be disappointed. Updated7/18/22 - Still amazing pizza! Read more
I can not find a current menu w prices anywhere. Only menus available do not have accurate prices, be sure to ask prices before... ordering. Everything is extremely inflated lately. Seem to be chasing profits by cutting quality and jacking prices. Also, checkthe seal on ur sodas and drinks before consuming!!! Read more
Best Pizza in Town! Always fresh high quality ingredients and it shows, can get crust thin just like NYC style. Almost always... baked to perfection. This place is truly on another level! Read more
Just ordered 2 subs 5 wings and breaded mushrooms. Cost was $ 40.00. I told the girl on the phone to toast the sub rolls extra... crispy. Mine was a little crispy around the top and the bottom not even a little cooked. Worst sub I have had from there in along time. When I order and pick up it is right but when I call for delivery this is what we get. It happened before. Cliffordered Buffalo chicken sub and they forgot his dipping sauce. Unacceptable order for 40.00. Will be going back to BB?s. Read more
Two dozen wings and two slices like the one below, for $40. Tough to even give 2 stars, but the wings were at least good size. ... The slice was comparable to 7-11. Not what I would expect from a pizzeria. The one in Bushnell?s Basin is way way better thanthis. Read more
I haven?t had Pontillo?s pizza in awhile, but it has always been considered the favorite pizza in my family. The pizza and wings... were just as I remembered and ready for pickup exactly on time. Staff was friendly and polite. It was nice to see that an orderof wings is still 12 good size pieces as most places now only serve 10. Will definitely order again. Thank you Mike for all theyears of serving delicious food to the people of your home town! Read more