Reviews for Village Square Pizza in New York, NY
Excellent pizza differentiated by its rectangular cut. Seed oil free options. Hot honey. Open late. Simple as.
Not sure if we came on a bad night, as was excited from reviews, then it didn't live up to expectations. I was a little... disappointed as I ordered, to then be told they didn't have what I ordered. Also, when the pizza came, it was quite cold (and weliterally say right outside to eat!) Read more
Don't order through Grubhub or you will have to ask for a refund. Food was good here, but Grubhub destroyed my order this time.... I called the restaurant 1st to resolve the matter, and instead offering a solution, I was told "That was Grubhub not us" andbrushed off. Manager then calls me to explain who's fault it is. ??????? Read more
Definitely one of the best pizzas ???? I?ve ever had ???????? The way they make the crust , the cheese and the pepperoni ????... is so delicious ???? I did have to walk a little but the service was fast , they had seating outside . I walked across thestreet and sat on a park bench . The honey hot ???? sauce is fire ???? it makes the pizza taste so good ! Can?t wait to comeback ! Add this place to your list of things to do Follow me on IG: childofgodliz85 ???????????????????????????? Read more
The vodka square is one of the best slices I?ve had in the city and their pepperoni square is easily in the top 5! Also worth... noting their staff is very friendly and makes the experience that much better Read more
An amazing thick crust that has a good flavor, is crisp yet chewy, for both the square and round slices. They have 2 vegan... options, average price per slice is $5 and a great tomato sauce. My only criticism was the amount of sauce in the pepperonislice we got. Given a thicker square crust, I would have liked to see a bit more sauce to have made it more enjoyable. Thevegan eggplant square and plain cheese slice were good too. Read more
Village Square Pizza is a solid pizza place on the Lower East Side. They have a good set of Sicilian and Regular style pizzas... that are all delicious. I recommend trying out the Pepperoni Sicilian and the Buffalo Chicken flavours. Read more
Unfortunately, their pizza certainly doesn't taste as good as it looks. We tried a slice of Grandma's, which was under-seasoned... with little excitement in the crust and the pepperoni/sausage pizza, which unfortunately was SO drenched in hot honey, wecouldn't taste anything but sauce. Shame because we've heard great things about this store, but it just doesn't seem to measureup against the other NY pizza classics. Read more