Reviews for Tortaria in New York, NY
The first rule of a Mexican restaurant is to serve the tortillas warm. Tacos with cold tortillas are NOT ok. The 2nd rule is to... make sure your salsas have flavor. This restaurant is definitely a restaurant for white people who want to eat in a prettyenvironment. I gave an extra star here for the decor. But a good interior decorator does not make a good cook. The food is blandand disappointing. Read more
This brunch was awesome. Two drinks and an entrée for $20, and everything was phenomenal. Service was great as well. We’ll... definitely be back soon. Read more
Incredible place to dine in. Food is delicious. The employees are very kind and take pictures of you and your company. My... boyfriend and I enjoyed it to the max. Totally recommend the nachos with the cheesy dip, it was fantastic. Read more
Cool Mexican spot that has fast and efficient service. Was super crowded and the manager was beyond accommodating in trying to... find us a seat inside. Offered several options including sitting at the bar until a table was located. Server was veryattentive. Disappointed they took the black bean soup off the menu but the blackened shrimp tacos and chips and salsa weredelicious. Drinks were good and strong. Read more
Is it my birthday?! The food is so special here! Simple, classic, and quality. I had the shredded chicken burrito and classic... house margarita on the rocks with salt. Both were delicious and so beautifully made. The burrito wrap was handmade, stretchy andfluffy, and grilled on one side. The filling was flavorful and perfectly seasoned, not needing but enhanced by the three saucesthat came on the side. The margarita was fresh, pure, clean and the salt rim was perfect. Long margarita and mezcal menu - youcould tell there is pride in their recipes. Nothing overdone - simple and spectacular. The service was courteous andprofessionals and the decor was really fun and colorful. Can’t wait to go back! Read more
The decor was authentic. The food was delicious and fresh. They have a number of different sauces for anyone to enjoy. The... frozen margaritas were kind of strong and flavorful. The staff was nice and accommodating. Everything was fairly priced.Definitely a good spot near Union square to hang out with friends. Read more
We visited Tortaria for their brunch special which includes two drinks and an entrée. Overall, it was fine but nothing to rave... about. Drinks were good and we appreciated the ambiance of the outdoor dining. The food was pretty basic, not bursting withflavor or anything, but the breakfast bowl was notable because the portion size was really large. The brunch price was alsoslightly higher than what was advertised in their menu online. Read more
Place is a hidden gem. Well I wouldn’t say hidden cause it’s in plane sight. I happened to walk by and saw a server with a... plate of fox and was like that looks good! Lol. So I turned around and sat in. And they did not disappoint. Steak Tacos weresooooo good , the sauce was good, and the vegetables were fresh!!! And the drinks were strong and good! I got a coconutmargarita! Good and refreshing! I love everything. The aesthetics were cool and calm and very pretty inside. Servers were niceand informative about what to order! Read more