Reviews for The Dutch in New York, NY

Nice place, great service and friendly atmosphere. But this place don’t have much things (interior layout and food menu)... Dutch. Very American style and some dishes were a ted salty for my palate. Read more

Had a reservation for my bf and I today at The Dutch. We started off with drinks which were a classic Margarita and a draft IPA.... Both were delicious and margaritas was well made and flavorful. Next we had the little Oyster sandwiches and an Asian Calamarisalad/appetizer. Both were also delicious and flavorful. My bf had the grass fed burger which was stacked high and he reallyenjoyed it. Fries were nice and crispy and well seasoned. I ordered the fried chicken which the Dutch is famous for. The chickenwas beautifully presented with wonderful flavorful and crispy skin, the coleslaw and the honey butter biscuits were absolutelyamazing! Now the problem started when I took a bite. My chicken was VERY undercooked and rubbery tasting. It didn't fall of thebone and was somewhat pink next to the bone which means it was undercooked. This is very dangerous as raw chicken can cause manyintestinal issues and problems. We were deciding on what to do and I promptly called our waitress and informed her of the issue.She was very apologetic and sweet, brought the whole dish back and said they will remake it for me again. During our wait, aman who I think was one of the managers came over and also apologized for the outcome of the dish. Everyone was veryunderstanding and wonderful. The second batch of the dish was perfect. Chicken was falling off the bone and cooked toperfection. They also comped one item off the menu as a courtesy for us. Now why did I take off a star? It seems like many otherreviewers mention the chicken being undercooked. For a restaurant that is branding itself as one where this particular dish ishighlighted and marketed heavily, I'd expect the chef to know how to prepare it flawlessly everytime. Perhaps better trainingand understanding of how to prepare a signature item should be implemented so guests don't have to send back undercookedpoultry. Just a thought. Otherwise everything else was great! Read more

Great place excellent staff warm and friendly. The food is good so tasty and fresh. The fried chicken is worth it . The oyster... ???? are good to with a variety of condiments to put on like fresh shaved horseradish or shallots in vinegar or typical oystersauce. The Biscuits are good . The beef tartare was nice not gummy. The fries ???? are so nice and fluffy and crispy. Read more

Food was Excellent, the ribs were a bit heavy on the salt but the rest was great. Quality is there but not quite up to the price... point. Scrambled eggs were surprisingly good Beverages were on the pricey side. $9 for a small iced coffee is steep. Read more

A very great spot for brunch, a date, or even just dinner. Cornmeal Blueberry flapjacks were my favorite!!! Then the breakfast... sanwhich (that biscuit was delicious) and of course oysters. Cant go anywhere without ordering these. Service was excellent! Read more

Came to the dutch during a Sunday afternoon to celebrate a friend's birthday. We got a really cute booth perfect for 4-5 to sit.... Waiters were attentive and the food was great, we got the fried chicken, burger, omelet. Unfortunately, there was a strand ofcurly human hair that came in the coleslaw of the chicken dish, so I have to knock off a point. Read more

Came here on Valentine’s Day with my wife, and surprisingly got a good table in the corner that wasn’t packed tight against... other tables. I had an old fashioned (no Bulleit bourbon which is my usual go to) and my wife got a vodka gimlet and both wereexcellent. My wife loved the burger, and I thought the fried chicken was good, not amazing. The real star of the show was thewhipped butter that came with the cornbread appetizer! Good vibe overall Read more

Eh did not ~hit~ like I wish it did. Known for/ hype up their fried chicken and it was burnt tasting. Meat was definitely moist... but the coating was bitter. Good drinks though. Would not go again Read more