Reviews for Seamore’s in New York, NY
I inhaled everything before remembering to take pics. Everything. Even the carrot & celery sticks that came with the Buffalo... shrimp. Best Buffalo shrimp I’ve ever had—taste like Buffalo wings. I ordered fish & chips. Inhaled the entire plate:tartar sauce, ketchup, malt vinegar, pickled cucumbers & carrots, battered cod (delightfully fresh, flavorful & hot), shoestringfries (served stylishly in mini wire fry basket), and complimentary water with lemon on the side. The prices are slightlypricey—after all, this establishment is located in Chelsea—but nothing I ate dissatisfied. Someone else picked up the tab soI gave 5 stars because criticism is hard to come by when the food is free. But had my $25 fish & chips come out of my pocket,I’d probably deduct a star. All in all, Seamore’s doesn’t disappoint and the waitstaff was very pleasant. I feel confidentrecommending this spot. Sidenote: I wore a KN95 mask the whole time and only removed while eating & drinking. I was lone personin a party of 5 to do this. My dinner companions, as was everyone else in the restaurant, straight raw dogged it. However, I didnot let peer pressure steal the joy of my delicious free seafood. If Covid-19 masking is a concern for you, you may want to optfor Seamore’s outdoor seating. (Addendum: Someone ordered churro ice cream at the last minute at the end. At first I politelydeclined a taste. “No, no, it’s good,” they replied. I agree, it’s good.) (Addendum 2: I only ordered fish &chips—$25–no drink, appetizer or dessert. If your party orders more than entrees or the costlier Reel of the Day, i.e.salmon, then average per guest cost is easily in the $30 to $50 range.) Read more
Had a great experience here! The patio is super nice and the food was great. The chips and guac were so fresh and the buffalo... shrimp surprised me it was so good! I had the lobster roll my boyfriend had the monkfish sandwich and his sandwich was better.The lobster roll was still good just not the best I've had. The fries were so thin and crispy. We will definitely be back forthe service and atmosphere too! Read more
Great place for a sunny day brunch if you’re into seafood. Lobster Benedict and Shrimps tacos were super tasty and they serve... great mimosas too. It’s not a cheap place though, so go prepared to spend a few more. Read more
I love seafood, and this place has great seafood dishes. The staff was incredibly friendly. I really enjoyed my late lunch... here. I can't wait to go back and try more and more of the menu Read more
Drinks and food were good. The bartender Prudence makes good drinks. I asked for a mezcal mule that it's not on the menu and it... was great. I had the hake w/ quinoa and chimichurri and I really enjoyed, just the perfect amount for a good meal. Read more
I like the food at seamore’s and that’s the only reason I go there however service could be better and most important -... faster. We were 3 people and placed an order at 3:04pm - 3 shrimp taco, burger, lobster Mac and cheese, steelhead sandwich.Since they didn’t have gluten free buns, i got it with a lettuce wrap. We got the corn shrimp tacos after 15 minutes and therest of the food after more than 50 minutes. When I inquired first (after 35 minutes) with one of the servers he came back toask me how I like my burger to be cooked (?!) and then when we saw that we’re still not getting the food I reached out to themanager. Who came back and told us that we’re only waiting 30 minutes and that the order was places after we finished thetaco. NO Apology, no even showing that she cares. Just dropped the plates and left. Too bad since I’m a regular at seamores(in 3 of their locations). I guess I’ll skip them now if they don’t care about my business. Read more
Overall, I rate Seamore’s 3 stars. The food was good, but not spectacular. To start we had the watermelon& heirloom tomato... salad with seared tuna on top. It was refreshing, and had a little kick to it with jalapeños. It was my favorite part of themeal. Next, my boyfriend and I split the chicken fajitas and shrimp tacos. The chicken was the better of the two. Shrimp wasgood, but lacking flavor. The experience and ambiance was lovely, but the food was a little underwhelming. I would go back forthe salad, but not the tacos. Read more
Good overall. $18 for this “watermelon salad” is a joke… but this is nyc for ya… Kids menu Mac and Cheese is good. Good... ambiance. For safety, they need to install a light outside the bathroom. The water temperature in the bathroom is like lava…trying to wash my hands, not to burn a layer of skin off… Read more