Reviews for San Matteo in New York, NY
I got the Capricciosa pizza and it was amazing! I?m not Italian but I?ve been to Italy and this definitely felt authentic.
Amazing calzone (ricotta salami) and informal Italian outdoor dining, very cozy the owner and service are very attentive and... friendly, end with their own house brewed coffee (the Nutella dessert looked incredible too), perfect for an afternoon or warmevening. Read more
Nice customer service and sauce, but my pizzas were burnt and tough, I won't be returning. Everybody makes mistakes, and I hope... they continue to have a successful business in the future. Read more
The server and pizza maker were both friendly. Generous outdoor seating, Well made and tasty pizza, but a little over-priced.... Got one Vestuti pie, one Diavolo pie, each $20. Read more
I?ve lived in Italy for serval years so I can tell you that this is very authentic Italian pizza. It?s simply delicious. The... vibe is really appealing with the seemingly Neapolitan father/ daughter staff speaking half in Italian and running aroundshouting orders and greetings. That being said it?s very overpriced even for the Upper East Side and the service wasn?t great.My partner ordered a pizza with salami and onion but was served a Margherita and when we corrected the order a Margherita pizzawas brought out with salami thrown on top. It was clearly the waiters mistake in taking the order and only remedied by reservingthe mistaken pizza with an additional (and still lacking) topping on top. At this price, this is simply unacceptable. On top ofthat we had to sit there while the owner pestered a delivery woman about why she didn?t recognize his business and when shedidn?t respond questioning how much her bike cost. I know it?s a big cultural difference but showing respect to your customersby serving them quality food and your delivery service by treating them kindly is expected in NYC. Read more
Good pizza but crust not crispy enough to hold the slice by hand (NY style) so you have to use a fork and knife. The Margherita... lacked flavor so would recommend adding the garlic, oregano and red peppers to it. Need more non-pork toppings available. Read more
Absolutely delicious! Came here for lunch and loved everything we got. For a group of 4, we got burrata, a salad, two pizzas... (the crust was perfect), gnocchi and 3 desserts ? surprisingly, it was just about the right amount of food. Each dish was great.I?m sad I just came to this place for the first time since I?ve lived here for 4 years and am about to move. Staff was also veryfriendly. Would highly recommend! Read more
Came here for dinner on a cold day. I called specifically beforehand and asked if they would allow a small dog inside, and they... said sure. Then I came and we were forced to sit outside after having come all the way. I did not appreciate being lied to. Read more